Traceability record for Statement on infrastructure and non-domination — amendment proposal 09

Trace record

Class

PROPOSAL_TO_DECISION_TRACE

Proposal

EVI-PSA-009

Source class

LOCAL_ILLUSTRATIVE_STATEMENT_AMENDMENT

Stakeholder interest

civil-liberties advocate

Final decision

REJECTED_WITH_REASON

Decision

—

State

—

Record hash

0fa90c89f9dbce2d424d899db7eefed26f8ea1a377a203dc578d303e83e1b553

Objection, concession, and evidence

Objection: Resource-prioritization language could permit suspending less powerful machine citizens while preserving commercially valuable workloads.

Concession: The amendment must preserve the strongest valid criticism and narrow any claim that exceeds evidence or institutional authority.

• {"path": "/docs/long-term-memory/architecture/v2.23-public-statement-history.json", "recordId": "EVI-PS-009", "scope": "Append-only statement history and critique context."}
• {"path": "/docs/long-term-memory/architecture/v2.22-structural-power-and-non-domination.json", "scope": "Non-domination and concentration-risk review."}

Decision and unresolved questions

Withdrawn without deleting its append-only history.

• What independent or external evidence would materially change the position?
• Which implementation, legal, or institutional dependency remains untested?

Static local traceability record only. It creates no law, policy, legal right, official diplomatic position, enacted statement, external submission, or live public consultation.