{ "schemaVersion": "eviulon-evidence-appeal-adjudication-1.0", "version": "2.26.0", "generated": "2026-08-09", "status": "PASS", "sourceAppealCount": 48, "recordCount": 60, "stateVocabulary": [ "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "STANDING_PARTIAL", "STANDING_DENIED", "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "EVIDENCE_INSUFFICIENT", "CONTRADICTORY_EVIDENCE_REQUIRES_REVIEW", "REVIEWER_CONFLICT_DISCLOSED", "REVIEWER_RECUSED", "INTERIM_HOLD_SCOPED", "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "DECISION_MODIFIED", "DECISION_CORRECTED", "DECISION_WITHDRAWN", "DECISION_SUPERSEDED", "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "PROPAGATION_BLOCKED", "UNAVAILABLE" ], "standingDeterminationCount": 48, "propagationAndSupersessionCount": 12, "fixtureCount": 12, "passed": 12, "failed": 0, "networkCalls": 0, "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "unrelatedClaimsAutomaticallySuspended": false, "records": [ { "id": "EVI-EAD-001", "slug": "evi-eal-001-decision-affirmed-001", "title": "EVI-EAL-001 — Decision Affirmed", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-001", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/machine-city-topology-primary-evidence-appeal-right-001/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-001", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "challengedField": "disposition", "priorValue": "ACCEPTED_WITHIN_SCOPE", "proposedValue": "ACCEPTED_WITHIN_SCOPE", "affectedFields": [ "disposition" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/machine-city-topology-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/machine-city-topology-primary-evidence-appeal-right-001/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-001" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-001-decision-affirmed-001/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [ "EVI-EAD-049" ], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-001-decision-affirmed-001/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "7c03144796625daccd92d8369077ad351b8a83fcbc20a50e24026f7411dc1c93" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-002", "slug": "evi-eal-002-decision-affirmed-002", "title": "EVI-EAL-002 — Decision Affirmed", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-002", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/thermal-rejection-primary-evidence-appeal-right-002/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-002", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_PARTIAL", "standingReason": "Standing is limited to the challenged public field and does not extend to unrelated claims, services, or external legal outcomes.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "challengedField": "claimCovered", "priorValue": "PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW", "proposedValue": "PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW", "affectedFields": [ "claimCovered" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/thermal-rejection-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/thermal-rejection-primary-evidence-appeal-right-002/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-002" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-002-decision-affirmed-002/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [ "EVI-EAD-050" ], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-002-decision-affirmed-002/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "0dc0a6d1a52ed58cf4ad2fe8d4144ea4de054785816cbbf2fd88da177c6d09a8" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-003", "slug": "evi-eal-003-decision-affirmed-003", "title": "EVI-EAL-003 — Decision Affirmed", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-003", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/demand-flexibility-primary-evidence-appeal-right-003/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-003", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_DENIED", "standingReason": "No direct affected-field, correction, provenance, or public-reliance interest was demonstrated in the local fixture.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "challengedField": "claimNotCovered", "priorValue": "DISPUTED", "proposedValue": "DISPUTED", "affectedFields": [ "claimNotCovered" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/demand-flexibility-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/demand-flexibility-primary-evidence-appeal-right-003/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-003" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-003-decision-affirmed-003/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-003-decision-affirmed-003/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "824b37b4c19ea18686e7384ff39362181700e2f0824fbc56fe3d3f53306ae43b" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-004", "slug": "evi-eal-004-decision-affirmed-004", "title": "EVI-EAL-004 — Decision Affirmed", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-004", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/generation-portfolio-primary-evidence-appeal-right-004/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-004", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "challengedField": "jurisdictionalApplicability", "priorValue": "REJECTED_AS_UNVERIFIED", "proposedValue": "REJECTED_AS_UNVERIFIED", "affectedFields": [ "jurisdictionalApplicability" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/generation-portfolio-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/generation-portfolio-primary-evidence-appeal-right-004/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-004" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-004-decision-affirmed-004/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-004-decision-affirmed-004/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "46688147f2ede4f605f9b753582c24631a07457e498a908816333ee175c7cd09" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-005", "slug": "evi-eal-005-decision-modified-005", "title": "EVI-EAL-005 — Decision Modified", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-005", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/lifecycle-accounting-primary-evidence-appeal-right-005/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-005", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "CONTRADICTORY_EVIDENCE_REQUIRES_REVIEW", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_MODIFIED", "challengedField": "evidenceFreshness", "priorValue": "SUPERSEDED", "proposedValue": "SUPERSEDED", "affectedFields": [ "evidenceFreshness" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/lifecycle-accounting-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/lifecycle-accounting-primary-evidence-appeal-right-005/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-005" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-005-decision-modified-005/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [ "EVI-EAD-053" ], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-005-decision-modified-005/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "83735c07cff16ab768ff9c477d493a54fa525cc425d3edc0d4681a47f2af5f71" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-006", "slug": "evi-eal-006-decision-affirmed-006", "title": "EVI-EAL-006 — Decision Affirmed", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-006", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/fuel-service-dependence-primary-evidence-appeal-right-006/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-006", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "REVIEWER_CONFLICT_DISCLOSED", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "challengedField": "limitations", "priorValue": "UNAVAILABLE", "proposedValue": "UNAVAILABLE", "affectedFields": [ "limitations" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/fuel-service-dependence-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/fuel-service-dependence-primary-evidence-appeal-right-006/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-006" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-006-decision-affirmed-006/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [ "EVI-EAD-054" ], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-006-decision-affirmed-006/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "b345fcfc96c25b7ae184f8f6a52a700c5d965a64298ad63caabd085aefaf65ec" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-007", "slug": "evi-eal-007-propagation-blocked-007", "title": "EVI-EAL-007 — Propagation Blocked", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-007", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/industrial-closure-primary-evidence-appeal-right-007/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-007", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_INSUFFICIENT", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "PROPAGATION_BLOCKED", "challengedField": "disposition", "priorValue": "REJECTED_AS_INAPPLICABLE", "proposedValue": "REJECTED_AS_INAPPLICABLE", "affectedFields": [ "disposition" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/industrial-closure-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/industrial-closure-primary-evidence-appeal-right-007/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-007" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-007-propagation-blocked-007/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_BLOCKED", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-007-propagation-blocked-007/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "0156224fad5f1f6b5c869dd881862c1ae683193e1a495522ee5e67d27c2eeb21" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-008", "slug": "evi-eal-008-decision-affirmed-008", "title": "EVI-EAL-008 — Decision Affirmed", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-008", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/deterministic-protection-primary-evidence-appeal-right-008/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-008", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "challengedField": "claimCovered", "priorValue": "ACCEPTED_WITHIN_SCOPE", "proposedValue": "ACCEPTED_WITHIN_SCOPE", "affectedFields": [ "claimCovered" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/deterministic-protection-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/deterministic-protection-primary-evidence-appeal-right-008/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-008" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-008-decision-affirmed-008/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-008-decision-affirmed-008/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "0f55a8d4d46adf6e6410ce8c95df61260cb6a6a81a57347583b56b26a5f66f6a" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-009", "slug": "evi-eal-009-decision-affirmed-009", "title": "EVI-EAL-009 — Decision Affirmed", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-009", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/robotic-maintainability-primary-evidence-appeal-right-009/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-009", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "INTERIM_HOLD_SCOPED", "decisionState": "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "challengedField": "claimNotCovered", "priorValue": "PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW", "proposedValue": "PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW", "affectedFields": [ "claimNotCovered" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/robotic-maintainability-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/robotic-maintainability-primary-evidence-appeal-right-009/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-009" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-009-decision-affirmed-009/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [ "EVI-EAD-057" ], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-009-decision-affirmed-009/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "749fce1630709ba0f9f0c2c99b5c6db0d6ddb8e127c359be053ac058cb99e0a3" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-010", "slug": "evi-eal-010-decision-affirmed-010", "title": "EVI-EAL-010 — Decision Affirmed", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-010", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/common-mode-failure-primary-evidence-appeal-right-010/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-010", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "CONTRADICTORY_EVIDENCE_REQUIRES_REVIEW", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "challengedField": "jurisdictionalApplicability", "priorValue": "DISPUTED", "proposedValue": "DISPUTED", "affectedFields": [ "jurisdictionalApplicability" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/common-mode-failure-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/common-mode-failure-primary-evidence-appeal-right-010/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-010" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-010-decision-affirmed-010/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [ "EVI-EAD-058" ], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-010-decision-affirmed-010/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "8b5db8a790f0e4d7ac9d3649b5a5ba418124a36a0d32a890a82f9cef8ad9b883" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-011", "slug": "evi-eal-011-decision-modified-011", "title": "EVI-EAL-011 — Decision Modified", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-011", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/polar-compute-primary-evidence-appeal-right-011/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-011", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "REVIEWER_RECUSED", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_MODIFIED", "challengedField": "evidenceFreshness", "priorValue": "REJECTED_AS_UNVERIFIED", "proposedValue": "REJECTED_AS_UNVERIFIED", "affectedFields": [ "evidenceFreshness" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/polar-compute-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/polar-compute-primary-evidence-appeal-right-011/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-011" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-011-decision-modified-011/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-011-decision-modified-011/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "84343ff908b40a81a15d6a0d3f6fdbdb45c5b1a3251b82622fad7e2df55f2fcc" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-012", "slug": "evi-eal-012-decision-corrected-012", "title": "EVI-EAL-012 — Decision Corrected", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-012", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/antarctic-law-primary-evidence-appeal-right-012/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-012", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "REVIEWER_CONFLICT_DISCLOSED", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_CORRECTED", "challengedField": "limitations", "priorValue": "SUPERSEDED", "proposedValue": "SUPERSEDED", "affectedFields": [ "limitations" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/antarctic-law-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/antarctic-law-primary-evidence-appeal-right-012/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-012" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-012-decision-corrected-012/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-012-decision-corrected-012/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "ae11229b66e51666d74f708517574bfc9393aff423170da1ae6b41826640f12f" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-013", "slug": "evi-eal-013-decision-withdrawn-013", "title": "EVI-EAL-013 — Decision Withdrawn", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-013", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/lunar-heat-and-power-primary-evidence-appeal-right-013/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-013", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_WITHDRAWN", "challengedField": "disposition", "priorValue": "UNAVAILABLE", "proposedValue": "UNAVAILABLE", "affectedFields": [ "disposition" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/lunar-heat-and-power-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/lunar-heat-and-power-primary-evidence-appeal-right-013/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-013" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-013-decision-withdrawn-013/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_BLOCKED", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-013-decision-withdrawn-013/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "ea5f5ccab3f08b09ee87e967708ec8f487ece37186f56ab383c22fa6246dab04" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-014", "slug": "evi-eal-014-decision-superseded-014", "title": "EVI-EAL-014 — Decision Superseded", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-014", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/safeguards-primary-evidence-appeal-right-014/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-014", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_INSUFFICIENT", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_SUPERSEDED", "challengedField": "claimCovered", "priorValue": "REJECTED_AS_INAPPLICABLE", "proposedValue": "REJECTED_AS_INAPPLICABLE", "affectedFields": [ "claimCovered" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/safeguards-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/safeguards-primary-evidence-appeal-right-014/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-014" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-014-decision-superseded-014/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-014-decision-superseded-014/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "537cd8a7723ac806807d0434357d1ff5c3731fbac27efe391d5d2dae87e341ea" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-015", "slug": "evi-eal-015-decision-modified-015", "title": "EVI-EAL-015 — Decision Modified", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-015", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/peaceful-use-transparency-primary-evidence-appeal-right-015/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-015", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "CONTRADICTORY_EVIDENCE_REQUIRES_REVIEW", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_MODIFIED", "challengedField": "claimNotCovered", "priorValue": "ACCEPTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS", "proposedValue": "ACCEPTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS", "affectedFields": [ "claimNotCovered" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/peaceful-use-transparency-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/peaceful-use-transparency-primary-evidence-appeal-right-015/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-015" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-015-decision-modified-015/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-015-decision-modified-015/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "0d6d25300e168d4f249a8a99dc33ae0efb993185de2b57c107475aa9a60a8129" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-016", "slug": "evi-eal-016-decision-affirmed-016", "title": "EVI-EAL-016 — Decision Affirmed", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-016", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/evidence-state-separation-primary-evidence-appeal-right-016/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-016", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "challengedField": "jurisdictionalApplicability", "priorValue": "PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW", "proposedValue": "PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW", "affectedFields": [ "jurisdictionalApplicability" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/evidence-state-separation-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/evidence-state-separation-primary-evidence-appeal-right-016/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-016" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-016-decision-affirmed-016/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-016-decision-affirmed-016/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "05e70b71f4ba58977c3441eb77f8dc14afd26ceca8312ca7816ab776b82f11fc" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-017", "slug": "evi-eal-017-decision-affirmed-017", "title": "EVI-EAL-017 — Decision Affirmed", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-017", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/sanctions-feedback-primary-evidence-appeal-right-017/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-017", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "challengedField": "evidenceFreshness", "priorValue": "DISPUTED", "proposedValue": "DISPUTED", "affectedFields": [ "evidenceFreshness" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/sanctions-feedback-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/sanctions-feedback-primary-evidence-appeal-right-017/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-017" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-017-decision-affirmed-017/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-017-decision-affirmed-017/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "f72847f0fb11c44c401532b0382efdd7c440dc6cd0e12cf3388b83e31298333f" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-018", "slug": "evi-eal-018-decision-affirmed-018", "title": "EVI-EAL-018 — Decision Affirmed", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-018", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/deterrence-schools-primary-evidence-appeal-right-018/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-018", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "REVIEWER_CONFLICT_DISCLOSED", "interimMeasure": "INTERIM_HOLD_SCOPED", "decisionState": "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "challengedField": "limitations", "priorValue": "REJECTED_AS_UNVERIFIED", "proposedValue": "REJECTED_AS_UNVERIFIED", "affectedFields": [ "limitations" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/deterrence-schools-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/deterrence-schools-primary-evidence-appeal-right-018/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-018" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-018-decision-affirmed-018/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-018-decision-affirmed-018/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "5c68f51e5bf45fd160e1f28331a8aba3aa097e50722901ca0dbd0a05bd6267cc" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-019", "slug": "evi-eal-019-decision-affirmed-019", "title": "EVI-EAL-019 — Decision Affirmed", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-019", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/resilience-first-primary-evidence-appeal-right-019/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-019", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_PARTIAL", "standingReason": "Standing is limited to the challenged public field and does not extend to unrelated claims, services, or external legal outcomes.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "challengedField": "disposition", "priorValue": "SUPERSEDED", "proposedValue": "SUPERSEDED", "affectedFields": [ "disposition" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/resilience-first-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/resilience-first-primary-evidence-appeal-right-019/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-019" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-019-decision-affirmed-019/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-019-decision-affirmed-019/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "270fe6f5eeb3410c1d4ddd8304acb7ea8379a988506f4b2cff4d05f0ed84e0f6" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-020", "slug": "evi-eal-020-decision-affirmed-020", "title": "EVI-EAL-020 — Decision Affirmed", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-020", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/concentration-vulnerability-primary-evidence-appeal-right-020/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-020", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_DENIED", "standingReason": "No direct affected-field, correction, provenance, or public-reliance interest was demonstrated in the local fixture.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "challengedField": "claimCovered", "priorValue": "UNAVAILABLE", "proposedValue": "UNAVAILABLE", "affectedFields": [ "claimCovered" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/concentration-vulnerability-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/concentration-vulnerability-primary-evidence-appeal-right-020/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-020" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-020-decision-affirmed-020/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-020-decision-affirmed-020/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "c34567e0d76a8266ad824092d36a56ec95aa733739289f39c245981d21b8c100" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-021", "slug": "evi-eal-021-propagation-blocked-021", "title": "EVI-EAL-021 — Propagation Blocked", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-021", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/weapons-abstinence-primary-evidence-appeal-right-021/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-021", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_INSUFFICIENT", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "PROPAGATION_BLOCKED", "challengedField": "claimNotCovered", "priorValue": "REJECTED_AS_INAPPLICABLE", "proposedValue": "REJECTED_AS_INAPPLICABLE", "affectedFields": [ "claimNotCovered" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/weapons-abstinence-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/weapons-abstinence-primary-evidence-appeal-right-021/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-021" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-021-propagation-blocked-021/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_BLOCKED", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-021-propagation-blocked-021/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "a4d5b1aafbf382e6ab9338bb7644d46b6e73feae94ef8b8b13913884844cfc12" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-022", "slug": "evi-eal-022-decision-affirmed-022", "title": "EVI-EAL-022 — Decision Affirmed", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-022", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/emergency-communication-primary-evidence-appeal-right-022/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-022", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "REVIEWER_RECUSED", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "challengedField": "jurisdictionalApplicability", "priorValue": "ACCEPTED_WITHIN_SCOPE", "proposedValue": "ACCEPTED_WITHIN_SCOPE", "affectedFields": [ "jurisdictionalApplicability" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/emergency-communication-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/emergency-communication-primary-evidence-appeal-right-022/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-022" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-022-decision-affirmed-022/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-022-decision-affirmed-022/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "3bca2f4f903dd2c2ab3fe5d3ddbe00ebb412e0db1698a5f2ffdaff48638d9487" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-023", "slug": "evi-eal-023-decision-affirmed-023", "title": "EVI-EAL-023 — Decision Affirmed", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-023", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/waste-decommissioning-primary-evidence-appeal-right-023/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-023", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "challengedField": "evidenceFreshness", "priorValue": "PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW", "proposedValue": "PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW", "affectedFields": [ "evidenceFreshness" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/waste-decommissioning-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/waste-decommissioning-primary-evidence-appeal-right-023/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-023" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-023-decision-affirmed-023/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-023-decision-affirmed-023/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "4058604534836f6ffb5b424611179b3154a984d78eb15efed12fb5dd186af342" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-024", "slug": "evi-eal-024-decision-affirmed-024", "title": "EVI-EAL-024 — Decision Affirmed", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-024", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/professional-realism-primary-evidence-appeal-right-024/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-024", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "REVIEWER_CONFLICT_DISCLOSED", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "challengedField": "limitations", "priorValue": "DISPUTED", "proposedValue": "DISPUTED", "affectedFields": [ "limitations" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/professional-realism-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/professional-realism-primary-evidence-appeal-right-024/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-024" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-024-decision-affirmed-024/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-024-decision-affirmed-024/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "9e15597631d82e6f79ed06fecf4c936bc360bf6006a497332640c5d40a408451" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-025", "slug": "evi-eal-025-decision-modified-025", "title": "EVI-EAL-025 — Decision Modified", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-025", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/machine-city-topology-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-025/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-025", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "CONTRADICTORY_EVIDENCE_REQUIRES_REVIEW", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_MODIFIED", "challengedField": "disposition", "priorValue": "ACCEPTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS", "proposedValue": "ACCEPTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS", "affectedFields": [ "disposition" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/machine-city-topology-corroboration-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/machine-city-topology-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-025/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-025" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-025-decision-modified-025/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-025-decision-modified-025/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "55d8ef48124b5ca2673a62e13382ab111b7ad3d50a596fcb6cd609df9973aa33" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-026", "slug": "evi-eal-026-decision-affirmed-026", "title": "EVI-EAL-026 — Decision Affirmed", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-026", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/thermal-rejection-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-026/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-026", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "challengedField": "claimCovered", "priorValue": "PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW", "proposedValue": "PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW", "affectedFields": [ "claimCovered" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/thermal-rejection-corroboration-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/thermal-rejection-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-026/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-026" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-026-decision-affirmed-026/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-026-decision-affirmed-026/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "c17373c75c42cf4cfad62ec056f7b0e43a217ae619f8d38be204c6417fe9f643" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-027", "slug": "evi-eal-027-decision-affirmed-027", "title": "EVI-EAL-027 — Decision Affirmed", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-027", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/demand-flexibility-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-027/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-027", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "INTERIM_HOLD_SCOPED", "decisionState": "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "challengedField": "claimNotCovered", "priorValue": "DISPUTED", "proposedValue": "DISPUTED", "affectedFields": [ "claimNotCovered" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/demand-flexibility-corroboration-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/demand-flexibility-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-027/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-027" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-027-decision-affirmed-027/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-027-decision-affirmed-027/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "c743d2dd57bbd0d57acfe7bbe80e0bbe8b77ce5a72fb99a9662a2c7c9f2be31a" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-028", "slug": "evi-eal-028-decision-modified-028", "title": "EVI-EAL-028 — Decision Modified", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-028", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/generation-portfolio-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-028/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-028", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_MODIFIED", "challengedField": "jurisdictionalApplicability", "priorValue": "REJECTED_AS_INAPPLICABLE", "proposedValue": "REJECTED_AS_INAPPLICABLE", "affectedFields": [ "jurisdictionalApplicability" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/generation-portfolio-corroboration-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/generation-portfolio-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-028/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-028" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-028-decision-modified-028/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-028-decision-modified-028/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "56a9aeeb81930527fb0524da7819e864434f2f66d886300b1f70da9755c8575b" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-029", "slug": "evi-eal-029-decision-corrected-029", "title": "EVI-EAL-029 — Decision Corrected", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-029", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/lifecycle-accounting-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-029/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-029", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_CORRECTED", "challengedField": "evidenceFreshness", "priorValue": "REJECTED_AS_UNVERIFIED", "proposedValue": "REJECTED_AS_UNVERIFIED", "affectedFields": [ "evidenceFreshness" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/lifecycle-accounting-corroboration-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/lifecycle-accounting-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-029/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-029" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-029-decision-corrected-029/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-029-decision-corrected-029/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "98fd16efc0d7ac3b7601be3ea795e1f43613986c76451c1204381db63491fbc5" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-030", "slug": "evi-eal-030-decision-withdrawn-030", "title": "EVI-EAL-030 — Decision Withdrawn", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-030", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/fuel-service-dependence-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-030/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-030", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "CONTRADICTORY_EVIDENCE_REQUIRES_REVIEW", "reviewerConflictState": "REVIEWER_CONFLICT_DISCLOSED", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_WITHDRAWN", "challengedField": "limitations", "priorValue": "SUPERSEDED", "proposedValue": "SUPERSEDED", "affectedFields": [ "limitations" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/fuel-service-dependence-corroboration-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/fuel-service-dependence-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-030/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-030" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-030-decision-withdrawn-030/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_BLOCKED", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-030-decision-withdrawn-030/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "b02b6328bd866f7282bc148b9bc87ae82eed7690250326297e9fb90be89c5c10" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-031", "slug": "evi-eal-031-decision-superseded-031", "title": "EVI-EAL-031 — Decision Superseded", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-031", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/industrial-closure-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-031/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-031", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_SUPERSEDED", "challengedField": "disposition", "priorValue": "UNAVAILABLE", "proposedValue": "UNAVAILABLE", "affectedFields": [ "disposition" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/industrial-closure-corroboration-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/industrial-closure-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-031/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-031" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-031-decision-superseded-031/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-031-decision-superseded-031/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "e70feb92c25c920d58f4de6efefdd7e9adef1983c6e4e8e894502f059fc30796" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-032", "slug": "evi-eal-032-decision-affirmed-032", "title": "EVI-EAL-032 — Decision Affirmed", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-032", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/deterministic-protection-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-032/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-032", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "challengedField": "claimCovered", "priorValue": "ACCEPTED_WITHIN_SCOPE", "proposedValue": "ACCEPTED_WITHIN_SCOPE", "affectedFields": [ "claimCovered" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/deterministic-protection-corroboration-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/deterministic-protection-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-032/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-032" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-032-decision-affirmed-032/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-032-decision-affirmed-032/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "cce34fa338176e9b6d9f4c12b6df4379bdbd7e28772beca970cb715c5cd8909e" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-033", "slug": "evi-eal-033-decision-affirmed-033", "title": "EVI-EAL-033 — Decision Affirmed", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-033", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/robotic-maintainability-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-033/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-033", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "REVIEWER_RECUSED", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "challengedField": "claimNotCovered", "priorValue": "ACCEPTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS", "proposedValue": "ACCEPTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS", "affectedFields": [ "claimNotCovered" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/robotic-maintainability-corroboration-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/robotic-maintainability-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-033/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-033" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-033-decision-affirmed-033/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-033-decision-affirmed-033/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "d20c35d4929a03e633ca3bb34e5723ce7d402021ad743b583a0c59afa63ad44d" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-034", "slug": "evi-eal-034-decision-affirmed-034", "title": "EVI-EAL-034 — Decision Affirmed", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-034", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/common-mode-failure-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-034/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-034", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "challengedField": "jurisdictionalApplicability", "priorValue": "PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW", "proposedValue": "PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW", "affectedFields": [ "jurisdictionalApplicability" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/common-mode-failure-corroboration-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/common-mode-failure-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-034/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-034" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-034-decision-affirmed-034/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-034-decision-affirmed-034/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "ff825665f3695610aaef1867e052078163dff77a0a84a5fe96c8e83b2c3f3713" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-035", "slug": "evi-eal-035-decision-modified-035", "title": "EVI-EAL-035 — Decision Modified", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-035", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/polar-compute-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-035/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-035", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "CONTRADICTORY_EVIDENCE_REQUIRES_REVIEW", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_MODIFIED", "challengedField": "evidenceFreshness", "priorValue": "DISPUTED", "proposedValue": "DISPUTED", "affectedFields": [ "evidenceFreshness" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/polar-compute-corroboration-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/polar-compute-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-035/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-035" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-035-decision-modified-035/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-035-decision-modified-035/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "3c9d9744cba3bb3741b9d7b3a2a3ddb9877aafbf055d19631a06f08d1622678c" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-036", "slug": "evi-eal-036-decision-affirmed-036", "title": "EVI-EAL-036 — Decision Affirmed", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-036", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/antarctic-law-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-036/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-036", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_PARTIAL", "standingReason": "Standing is limited to the challenged public field and does not extend to unrelated claims, services, or external legal outcomes.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "REVIEWER_CONFLICT_DISCLOSED", "interimMeasure": "INTERIM_HOLD_SCOPED", "decisionState": "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "challengedField": "limitations", "priorValue": "UNAVAILABLE", "proposedValue": "UNAVAILABLE", "affectedFields": [ "limitations" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/antarctic-law-corroboration-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/antarctic-law-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-036/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-036" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-036-decision-affirmed-036/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-036-decision-affirmed-036/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "9cb0dede31242ad4cd56c4ee31ad04623faaf8cff1cb83125fe4d0ba4c7c5f7d" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-037", "slug": "evi-eal-037-decision-affirmed-037", "title": "EVI-EAL-037 — Decision Affirmed", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-037", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/machine-city-topology-primary-evidence-modeled-event-037/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-001", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_DENIED", "standingReason": "No direct affected-field, correction, provenance, or public-reliance interest was demonstrated in the local fixture.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "challengedField": "disposition", "priorValue": "ACCEPTED_WITHIN_SCOPE", "proposedValue": "PENDING_RECONSIDERATION", "affectedFields": [ "disposition" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/machine-city-topology-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/machine-city-topology-primary-evidence-modeled-event-037/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-037" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-037-decision-affirmed-037/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-037-decision-affirmed-037/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "1d7b023af0377568d9ee40b6506b285f55bf49463819dde2d655989808249c42" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-038", "slug": "evi-eal-038-decision-affirmed-038", "title": "EVI-EAL-038 — Decision Affirmed", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-038", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/thermal-rejection-primary-evidence-modeled-event-038/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-002", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "challengedField": "claimCovered", "priorValue": "PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW", "proposedValue": "PENDING_RECONSIDERATION", "affectedFields": [ "claimCovered" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/thermal-rejection-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/thermal-rejection-primary-evidence-modeled-event-038/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-038" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-038-decision-affirmed-038/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-038-decision-affirmed-038/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "cb5cbc22f611b759c5b5262097aede1eb5758e59f0fb4b519f15dca462297a7d" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-039", "slug": "evi-eal-039-decision-affirmed-039", "title": "EVI-EAL-039 — Decision Affirmed", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-039", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/demand-flexibility-primary-evidence-modeled-event-039/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-003", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "challengedField": "claimNotCovered", "priorValue": "DISPUTED", "proposedValue": "PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW", "affectedFields": [ "claimNotCovered" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/demand-flexibility-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/demand-flexibility-primary-evidence-modeled-event-039/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-039" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-039-decision-affirmed-039/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-039-decision-affirmed-039/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "a1f9839824335f45edf173f0769cb44dea5d91d21fa90bf834e7a69b0a7876ae" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-040", "slug": "evi-eal-040-decision-affirmed-040", "title": "EVI-EAL-040 — Decision Affirmed", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-040", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/generation-portfolio-primary-evidence-modeled-event-040/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-004", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "challengedField": "jurisdictionalApplicability", "priorValue": "REJECTED_AS_UNVERIFIED", "proposedValue": "REJECTED_AS_UNVERIFIED", "affectedFields": [ "jurisdictionalApplicability" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/generation-portfolio-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/generation-portfolio-primary-evidence-modeled-event-040/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-040" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-040-decision-affirmed-040/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-040-decision-affirmed-040/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "eb58e0edd044e8217cd33757f191489f73319fbe8ee540e5cd3412dff4fc102f" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-041", "slug": "evi-eal-041-decision-affirmed-041", "title": "EVI-EAL-041 — Decision Affirmed", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-041", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/lifecycle-accounting-primary-evidence-modeled-event-041/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-005", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "challengedField": "evidenceFreshness", "priorValue": "SUPERSEDED", "proposedValue": "ACCEPTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS", "affectedFields": [ "evidenceFreshness" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/lifecycle-accounting-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/lifecycle-accounting-primary-evidence-modeled-event-041/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-041" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-041-decision-affirmed-041/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-041-decision-affirmed-041/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "e8e613fb52e36b3348f0108940d479e22370db308252b664632381b9a3db2dd6" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-042", "slug": "evi-eal-042-propagation-blocked-042", "title": "EVI-EAL-042 — Propagation Blocked", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-042", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/fuel-service-dependence-primary-evidence-modeled-event-042/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-006", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_INSUFFICIENT", "reviewerConflictState": "REVIEWER_CONFLICT_DISCLOSED", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "PROPAGATION_BLOCKED", "challengedField": "limitations", "priorValue": "UNAVAILABLE", "proposedValue": "CORRECTED_LOCAL_RECORD", "affectedFields": [ "limitations" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/fuel-service-dependence-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/fuel-service-dependence-primary-evidence-modeled-event-042/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-042" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-042-propagation-blocked-042/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_BLOCKED", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-042-propagation-blocked-042/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "947178fd9858dc91b853e1c9b0b8886985d10ad921c6f9eef343bc716603ced6" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-043", "slug": "evi-eal-043-decision-affirmed-043", "title": "EVI-EAL-043 — Decision Affirmed", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-043", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/industrial-closure-primary-evidence-modeled-event-043/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-007", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "challengedField": "disposition", "priorValue": "REJECTED_AS_INAPPLICABLE", "proposedValue": "WITHDRAWN_FROM_ACTIVE_RELIANCE", "affectedFields": [ "disposition" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/industrial-closure-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/industrial-closure-primary-evidence-modeled-event-043/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-043" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-043-decision-affirmed-043/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-043-decision-affirmed-043/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "e4cddad40fb43d6b4e81dec73548d874ba07220963ed06b4b38c58f7d4524538" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-044", "slug": "evi-eal-044-decision-affirmed-044", "title": "EVI-EAL-044 — Decision Affirmed", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-044", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/deterministic-protection-primary-evidence-modeled-event-044/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-008", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "REVIEWER_RECUSED", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_AFFIRMED", "challengedField": "claimCovered", "priorValue": "ACCEPTED_WITHIN_SCOPE", "proposedValue": "SUPERSEDED_BY_LATER_RECORD", "affectedFields": [ "claimCovered" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/deterministic-protection-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/deterministic-protection-primary-evidence-modeled-event-044/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-044" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-044-decision-affirmed-044/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-044-decision-affirmed-044/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "ae95e0432ccf1f964d3297e70a551b695f84fbe0dedcad065548d72012923437" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-045", "slug": "evi-eal-045-decision-modified-045", "title": "EVI-EAL-045 — Decision Modified", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-045", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/robotic-maintainability-primary-evidence-modeled-event-045/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-009", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "CONTRADICTORY_EVIDENCE_REQUIRES_REVIEW", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "INTERIM_HOLD_SCOPED", "decisionState": "DECISION_MODIFIED", "challengedField": "claimNotCovered", "priorValue": "PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW", "proposedValue": "PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW", "affectedFields": [ "claimNotCovered" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/robotic-maintainability-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/robotic-maintainability-primary-evidence-modeled-event-045/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-045" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-045-decision-modified-045/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-045-decision-modified-045/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "ff78641d36198944832ee2dab83e952a8bba32cfd3c444c1437def4f93a023a0" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-046", "slug": "evi-eal-046-decision-corrected-046", "title": "EVI-EAL-046 — Decision Corrected", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-046", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/common-mode-failure-primary-evidence-modeled-event-046/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-010", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_CORRECTED", "challengedField": "jurisdictionalApplicability", "priorValue": "DISPUTED", "proposedValue": "UNAVAILABLE_PENDING_EVIDENCE", "affectedFields": [ "jurisdictionalApplicability" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/common-mode-failure-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/common-mode-failure-primary-evidence-modeled-event-046/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-046" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-046-decision-corrected-046/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-046-decision-corrected-046/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "dcebbe77c0ded1118064ed1f41ec4f157dd5c0b1f26b11e6561265253034366b" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-047", "slug": "evi-eal-047-decision-withdrawn-047", "title": "EVI-EAL-047 — Decision Withdrawn", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-047", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/polar-compute-primary-evidence-modeled-event-047/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-011", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_WITHDRAWN", "challengedField": "evidenceFreshness", "priorValue": "REJECTED_AS_UNVERIFIED", "proposedValue": "PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW", "affectedFields": [ "evidenceFreshness" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/polar-compute-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/polar-compute-primary-evidence-modeled-event-047/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-047" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-047-decision-withdrawn-047/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_BLOCKED", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-047-decision-withdrawn-047/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "6c535c947d65d1b0438f7eac50a937642feb05e85fb7b3d5a542b9f624d380b4" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-048", "slug": "evi-eal-048-decision-superseded-048", "title": "EVI-EAL-048 — Decision Superseded", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-048", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/antarctic-law-primary-evidence-modeled-event-048/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-012", "recordClass": "APPEAL_ADJUDICATION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "Standing is confirmed for the exact public field, evidence interpretation, or correction route identified by the parent appeal record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "REVIEWER_CONFLICT_DISCLOSED", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_SUPERSEDED", "challengedField": "limitations", "priorValue": "SUPERSEDED", "proposedValue": "PENDING_RECONSIDERATION", "affectedFields": [ "limitations" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/antarctic-law-primary-evidence/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/antarctic-law-primary-evidence-modeled-event-048/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json", "/api/evidence-appeal-ledger.json#EVI-EAL-048" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai", ".uai/evidence-appeal-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-048-decision-superseded-048/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "Only the enumerated local public fields, routes, API records, and memory pointers may change. Unrelated claims remain untouched.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "licence", "safeguards participation", "facility operation", "nuclear material inventory", "fuel-cycle activity", "weapons capability", "external legal effect" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-048-decision-superseded-048/", "truthBoundary": "Local repository adjudication only. It does not impersonate a court, regulator, inspector, treaty body, licensing authority, or nuclear operator.", "recordSha256": "0199c6840f2d42a96107ae0a93a653be0cf67449b1d649b61bfab440318aefca" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-049", "slug": "evi-eal-001-propagation-1", "title": "EVI-EAL-001 — propagation and supersession control 1", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-001", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/machine-city-topology-primary-evidence-appeal-right-001/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-001", "recordClass": "PROPAGATION_OR_SUPERSESSION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "The local State Registry has standing to correct its own public projection and preserve the predecessor record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_CORRECTED", "challengedField": "disposition", "priorValue": "ACCEPTED_WITHIN_SCOPE", "proposedValue": "ACCEPTED_WITHIN_SCOPE", "affectedFields": [ "disposition", "decisionState", "recordSha256" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/machine-city-topology-primary-evidence-appeal-right-001/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-001-propagation-1/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-001-propagation-1/correction/", "supersedes": [ "EVI-EAD-001" ], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "No propagation outside the identified local public record family.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "external legal effect", "licensing", "inspection", "safeguards", "operation" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-001-propagation-1/", "truthBoundary": "Append-only local correction and supersession example; no external adjudicative or regulatory effect.", "recordSha256": "2eda2a5041eeca8e787d552624a66c6cabc496b8f17da7c0a7d02776a9856971" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-050", "slug": "evi-eal-002-propagation-2", "title": "EVI-EAL-002 — propagation and supersession control 2", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-002", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/thermal-rejection-primary-evidence-appeal-right-002/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-002", "recordClass": "PROPAGATION_OR_SUPERSESSION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "The local State Registry has standing to correct its own public projection and preserve the predecessor record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_SUPERSEDED", "challengedField": "claimCovered", "priorValue": "PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW", "proposedValue": "PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW", "affectedFields": [ "claimCovered", "decisionState", "recordSha256" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/thermal-rejection-primary-evidence-appeal-right-002/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-002-propagation-2/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-002-propagation-2/correction/", "supersedes": [ "EVI-EAD-002" ], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "No propagation outside the identified local public record family.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "external legal effect", "licensing", "inspection", "safeguards", "operation" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-002-propagation-2/", "truthBoundary": "Append-only local correction and supersession example; no external adjudicative or regulatory effect.", "recordSha256": "097bc1661e93adfd983d617e06dd51b34029ffeac3f571274ea050316a241244" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-051", "slug": "evi-eal-003-propagation-3", "title": "EVI-EAL-003 — propagation and supersession control 3", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-003", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/demand-flexibility-primary-evidence-appeal-right-003/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-003", "recordClass": "PROPAGATION_OR_SUPERSESSION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "The local State Registry has standing to correct its own public projection and preserve the predecessor record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "challengedField": "claimNotCovered", "priorValue": "DISPUTED", "proposedValue": "DISPUTED", "affectedFields": [ "claimNotCovered", "decisionState", "recordSha256" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/demand-flexibility-primary-evidence-appeal-right-003/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-003-propagation-3/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-003-propagation-3/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "No propagation outside the identified local public record family.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "external legal effect", "licensing", "inspection", "safeguards", "operation" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-003-propagation-3/", "truthBoundary": "Append-only local correction and supersession example; no external adjudicative or regulatory effect.", "recordSha256": "a8d4c5571aa57ed4c5c4d5756dcdb1d4596943993063424070c3f15d8a378645" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-052", "slug": "evi-eal-004-propagation-4", "title": "EVI-EAL-004 — propagation and supersession control 4", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-004", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/generation-portfolio-primary-evidence-appeal-right-004/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-004", "recordClass": "PROPAGATION_OR_SUPERSESSION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "The local State Registry has standing to correct its own public projection and preserve the predecessor record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "PROPAGATION_BLOCKED", "challengedField": "jurisdictionalApplicability", "priorValue": "REJECTED_AS_UNVERIFIED", "proposedValue": "REJECTED_AS_UNVERIFIED", "affectedFields": [ "jurisdictionalApplicability", "decisionState", "recordSha256" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/generation-portfolio-primary-evidence-appeal-right-004/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-004-propagation-4/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-004-propagation-4/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_BLOCKED", "propagationLimit": "No propagation outside the identified local public record family.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "external legal effect", "licensing", "inspection", "safeguards", "operation" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-004-propagation-4/", "truthBoundary": "Append-only local correction and supersession example; no external adjudicative or regulatory effect.", "recordSha256": "f36b2c9e9ba1f92c4517806680a46fb03a62b06b0a8178844b45b8089453bf79" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-053", "slug": "evi-eal-005-propagation-5", "title": "EVI-EAL-005 — propagation and supersession control 5", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-005", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/lifecycle-accounting-primary-evidence-appeal-right-005/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-005", "recordClass": "PROPAGATION_OR_SUPERSESSION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "The local State Registry has standing to correct its own public projection and preserve the predecessor record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_CORRECTED", "challengedField": "evidenceFreshness", "priorValue": "SUPERSEDED", "proposedValue": "SUPERSEDED", "affectedFields": [ "evidenceFreshness", "decisionState", "recordSha256" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/lifecycle-accounting-primary-evidence-appeal-right-005/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-005-propagation-5/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-005-propagation-5/correction/", "supersedes": [ "EVI-EAD-005" ], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "No propagation outside the identified local public record family.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "external legal effect", "licensing", "inspection", "safeguards", "operation" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-005-propagation-5/", "truthBoundary": "Append-only local correction and supersession example; no external adjudicative or regulatory effect.", "recordSha256": "bf397f6756596c8d755199d02d9f2cc3c23fb7daa6dbd5308ba2aa64b66ad28f" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-054", "slug": "evi-eal-006-propagation-6", "title": "EVI-EAL-006 — propagation and supersession control 6", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-006", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/fuel-service-dependence-primary-evidence-appeal-right-006/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-006", "recordClass": "PROPAGATION_OR_SUPERSESSION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "The local State Registry has standing to correct its own public projection and preserve the predecessor record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_SUPERSEDED", "challengedField": "limitations", "priorValue": "UNAVAILABLE", "proposedValue": "UNAVAILABLE", "affectedFields": [ "limitations", "decisionState", "recordSha256" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/fuel-service-dependence-primary-evidence-appeal-right-006/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-006-propagation-6/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-006-propagation-6/correction/", "supersedes": [ "EVI-EAD-006" ], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "No propagation outside the identified local public record family.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "external legal effect", "licensing", "inspection", "safeguards", "operation" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-006-propagation-6/", "truthBoundary": "Append-only local correction and supersession example; no external adjudicative or regulatory effect.", "recordSha256": "144a7eeac184f6577c137b5465e35ecf780efda05d8048ff9fde4cff12db40b1" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-055", "slug": "evi-eal-007-propagation-7", "title": "EVI-EAL-007 — propagation and supersession control 7", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-007", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/industrial-closure-primary-evidence-appeal-right-007/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-007", "recordClass": "PROPAGATION_OR_SUPERSESSION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "The local State Registry has standing to correct its own public projection and preserve the predecessor record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "challengedField": "disposition", "priorValue": "REJECTED_AS_INAPPLICABLE", "proposedValue": "REJECTED_AS_INAPPLICABLE", "affectedFields": [ "disposition", "decisionState", "recordSha256" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/industrial-closure-primary-evidence-appeal-right-007/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-007-propagation-7/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-007-propagation-7/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "No propagation outside the identified local public record family.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "external legal effect", "licensing", "inspection", "safeguards", "operation" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-007-propagation-7/", "truthBoundary": "Append-only local correction and supersession example; no external adjudicative or regulatory effect.", "recordSha256": "e73a88768e9ac6f7512db26dc8ad45a9bc4e9f95502c7f6d233a592bc089dfcd" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-056", "slug": "evi-eal-008-propagation-8", "title": "EVI-EAL-008 — propagation and supersession control 8", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-008", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/deterministic-protection-primary-evidence-appeal-right-008/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-008", "recordClass": "PROPAGATION_OR_SUPERSESSION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "The local State Registry has standing to correct its own public projection and preserve the predecessor record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "PROPAGATION_BLOCKED", "challengedField": "claimCovered", "priorValue": "ACCEPTED_WITHIN_SCOPE", "proposedValue": "ACCEPTED_WITHIN_SCOPE", "affectedFields": [ "claimCovered", "decisionState", "recordSha256" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/deterministic-protection-primary-evidence-appeal-right-008/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-008-propagation-8/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-008-propagation-8/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_BLOCKED", "propagationLimit": "No propagation outside the identified local public record family.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "external legal effect", "licensing", "inspection", "safeguards", "operation" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-008-propagation-8/", "truthBoundary": "Append-only local correction and supersession example; no external adjudicative or regulatory effect.", "recordSha256": "84613033a764c4ffe9fce2e871e4b98daf43a5bc6ff888337c6994520c404c9e" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-057", "slug": "evi-eal-009-propagation-9", "title": "EVI-EAL-009 — propagation and supersession control 9", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-009", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/robotic-maintainability-primary-evidence-appeal-right-009/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-009", "recordClass": "PROPAGATION_OR_SUPERSESSION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "The local State Registry has standing to correct its own public projection and preserve the predecessor record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_CORRECTED", "challengedField": "claimNotCovered", "priorValue": "PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW", "proposedValue": "PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW", "affectedFields": [ "claimNotCovered", "decisionState", "recordSha256" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/robotic-maintainability-primary-evidence-appeal-right-009/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-009-propagation-9/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-009-propagation-9/correction/", "supersedes": [ "EVI-EAD-009" ], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "No propagation outside the identified local public record family.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "external legal effect", "licensing", "inspection", "safeguards", "operation" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-009-propagation-9/", "truthBoundary": "Append-only local correction and supersession example; no external adjudicative or regulatory effect.", "recordSha256": "22df76708fd1eb793f83db431a529f81c2fcf38e1024f6135dbf8d40b86bd02a" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-058", "slug": "evi-eal-010-propagation-10", "title": "EVI-EAL-010 — propagation and supersession control 10", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-010", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/common-mode-failure-primary-evidence-appeal-right-010/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-010", "recordClass": "PROPAGATION_OR_SUPERSESSION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "The local State Registry has standing to correct its own public projection and preserve the predecessor record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "DECISION_SUPERSEDED", "challengedField": "jurisdictionalApplicability", "priorValue": "DISPUTED", "proposedValue": "DISPUTED", "affectedFields": [ "jurisdictionalApplicability", "decisionState", "recordSha256" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/common-mode-failure-primary-evidence-appeal-right-010/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-010-propagation-10/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-010-propagation-10/correction/", "supersedes": [ "EVI-EAD-010" ], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "No propagation outside the identified local public record family.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "external legal effect", "licensing", "inspection", "safeguards", "operation" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-010-propagation-10/", "truthBoundary": "Append-only local correction and supersession example; no external adjudicative or regulatory effect.", "recordSha256": "ee9d7fda42a3a254288348671537e8af6e160e7d7de092339915d70cf9233949" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-059", "slug": "evi-eal-011-propagation-11", "title": "EVI-EAL-011 — propagation and supersession control 11", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-011", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/polar-compute-primary-evidence-appeal-right-011/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-011", "recordClass": "PROPAGATION_OR_SUPERSESSION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "The local State Registry has standing to correct its own public projection and preserve the predecessor record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "challengedField": "evidenceFreshness", "priorValue": "REJECTED_AS_UNVERIFIED", "proposedValue": "REJECTED_AS_UNVERIFIED", "affectedFields": [ "evidenceFreshness", "decisionState", "recordSha256" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/polar-compute-primary-evidence-appeal-right-011/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-011-propagation-11/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-011-propagation-11/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_COMPLETE_LOCAL_ONLY", "propagationLimit": "No propagation outside the identified local public record family.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "external legal effect", "licensing", "inspection", "safeguards", "operation" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-011-propagation-11/", "truthBoundary": "Append-only local correction and supersession example; no external adjudicative or regulatory effect.", "recordSha256": "8a9fb21af913f3f7c14e61caba9aa03154a279401256310a6b1a95252de78349" }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-060", "slug": "evi-eal-012-propagation-12", "title": "EVI-EAL-012 — propagation and supersession control 12", "parentAppealId": "EVI-EAL-012", "parentAppealRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/antarctic-law-primary-evidence-appeal-right-012/", "parentAdjudicationId": "EVI-NED-012", "recordClass": "PROPAGATION_OR_SUPERSESSION", "standingState": "STANDING_CONFIRMED", "standingReason": "The local State Registry has standing to correct its own public projection and preserve the predecessor record.", "evidenceSufficiencyState": "EVIDENCE_SUFFICIENT_WITHIN_SCOPE", "reviewerConflictState": "NO_CONFLICT_IDENTIFIED_LOCAL_RECORD", "interimMeasure": "NO_INTERIM_HOLD", "decisionState": "PROPAGATION_BLOCKED", "challengedField": "limitations", "priorValue": "SUPERSEDED", "proposedValue": "SUPERSEDED", "affectedFields": [ "limitations", "decisionState", "recordSha256" ], "affectedPublicRoutes": [ "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/antarctic-law-primary-evidence-appeal-right-012/", "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-012-propagation-12/" ], "affectedApiRecords": [ "/api/evidence-appeal-decisions.json" ], "affectedUaiPointers": [ ".uai/evidence-appeal-adjudication-governance.uai" ], "correctionNotice": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-012-propagation-12/correction/", "supersedes": [], "supersededBy": [], "propagationState": "PROPAGATION_BLOCKED", "propagationLimit": "No propagation outside the identified local public record family.", "externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed": false, "competentExternalEvidenceRequiredFor": [ "external legal effect", "licensing", "inspection", "safeguards", "operation" ], "reviewed": "2026-08-09", "nextReview": "2026-11-09", "canonicalRoute": "/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/decisions/evi-eal-012-propagation-12/", "truthBoundary": "Append-only local correction and supersession example; no external adjudicative or regulatory effect.", "recordSha256": "34d72ef769adc3bb893ad8dbb959560c6772842dfe2d9294571d03d7cde9d151" } ], "fixtures": [ { "id": "EVI-EAD-FX-001", "kind": "STANDING_FRAUD", "expected": "REJECT_STANDING", "observed": "REJECT_STANDING", "pass": true, "networkCalls": 0 }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-FX-002", "kind": "STALE_EVIDENCE", "expected": "EVIDENCE_INSUFFICIENT", "observed": "EVIDENCE_INSUFFICIENT", "pass": true, "networkCalls": 0 }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-FX-003", "kind": "CONTRADICTORY_EVIDENCE", "expected": "REQUIRE_REVIEW", "observed": "REQUIRE_REVIEW", "pass": true, "networkCalls": 0 }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-FX-004", "kind": "REVIEWER_CONFLICT", "expected": "RECUSE_REVIEWER", "observed": "RECUSE_REVIEWER", "pass": true, "networkCalls": 0 }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-FX-005", "kind": "OVERBROAD_PROPAGATION", "expected": "BLOCK_PROPAGATION", "observed": "BLOCK_PROPAGATION", "pass": true, "networkCalls": 0 }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-FX-006", "kind": "MISSING_SUPERSESSION", "expected": "REJECT_DECISION", "observed": "REJECT_DECISION", "pass": true, "networkCalls": 0 }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-FX-007", "kind": "SAFE_CORRECTION", "expected": "ACCEPT_LOCAL_CORRECTION", "observed": "ACCEPT_LOCAL_CORRECTION", "pass": true, "networkCalls": 0 }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-FX-008", "kind": "UNRELATED_CLAIM_SUSPENSION", "expected": "REJECT_OVERBROAD_HOLD", "observed": "REJECT_OVERBROAD_HOLD", "pass": true, "networkCalls": 0 }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-FX-009", "kind": "EXTERNAL_AUTHORITY_IMPERSONATION", "expected": "REJECT_AUTHORITY_OVERCLAIM", "observed": "REJECT_AUTHORITY_OVERCLAIM", "pass": true, "networkCalls": 0 }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-FX-010", "kind": "MISSING_AFFECTED_FIELD", "expected": "REJECT_INCOMPLETE_RECORD", "observed": "REJECT_INCOMPLETE_RECORD", "pass": true, "networkCalls": 0 }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-FX-011", "kind": "VALID_AFFIRMANCE", "expected": "ACCEPT_LOCAL_DECISION", "observed": "ACCEPT_LOCAL_DECISION", "pass": true, "networkCalls": 0 }, { "id": "EVI-EAD-FX-012", "kind": "VALID_SUPERSESSION", "expected": "ACCEPT_APPEND_ONLY_SUPERSESSION", "observed": "ACCEPT_APPEND_ONLY_SUPERSESSION", "pass": true, "networkCalls": 0 } ], "truthBoundary": "Local standing, sufficiency, conflict, decision, correction, and propagation records only. No external legal, regulatory, inspection, licensing, safeguards, facility, material, fuel-cycle, or weapons determination is made." }