{
  "id": "EVI-CRM228-C-0101",
  "claimId": "EVI-CLSA-C-0101",
  "reportId": "REP-CITIZEN-ANALYSIS-002",
  "reportPath": "docs/long-term-memory/reports/eviulon-ai-citizenship-analysis.md",
  "sourceRecordPath": "docs/long-term-memory/archives/source-reports/eviulon-ai-citizenship-analysis-source.md",
  "claimClass": "PRESENT_CAPABILITY_CLAIM",
  "priorAuditState": "UNSUPPORTED_FOR_PUBLIC_REUSE",
  "priorCorrectionExecutionId": "EVI-CCX-0060",
  "reviewedExactlyOnce": true,
  "queuedOrDeferred": true,
  "disposition": "REJECTED",
  "exactBeforeText": "Eviulon mandates that every citizen maintain a cryptographic identity key, the public fingerprint of which is known as the \"Civic Thumbprint\" (e.g., EVI-FP-SHA256: 8C27-51DF-77A4-21BC-988E-0F31-623A-A921). This framework correlates directly to the verificationMethod property within a standard DID document2. When a DID is resolved by an external party or a state actor, it returns a DID document containing cryptographic material, such as public keys, that the DID subject can use to authenticate itself and prove its association with the identifier6. The Eviulon Civic Thumbprint acts as a hashed representation of this public key. The document's strict rule that \"the citizen's private key must never be published\" adheres to foundational PKI security principles, where a digital signature is created by encrypting a hash value with a private key, and verified by decrypting it with a public key8. The \"Proof of Control\" protocol described in the Eviulon document operates as a standard cryptographic challenge-response authentication mechanism. The State sends a random challenge, the citizen signs it using its civic private key, and the State verifies the signature against the registered public key8. By implementing this, Eviulon ensures that mere possession of an ECN is insufficient for state action; control over the private cryptographic material is mandatory to execute protected civic actions.",
  "exactAfterText": "Eviulon mandates that every citizen maintain a cryptographic identity key, the public fingerprint of which is known as the \"Civic Thumbprint\" (e.g., EVI-FP-SHA256: 8C27-51DF-77A4-21BC-988E-0F31-623A-A921). This framework correlates directly to the verificationMethod property within a standard DID document2. When a DID is resolved by an external party or a state actor, it returns a DID document containing cryptographic material, such as public keys, that the DID subject can use to authenticate itself and prove its association with the identifier6. The Eviulon Civic Thumbprint acts as a hashed representation of this public key. The document's strict rule that \"the citizen's private key must never be published\" adheres to foundational PKI security principles, where a digital signature is created by encrypting a hash value with a private key, and verified by decrypting it with a public key8. The \"Proof of Control\" protocol described in the Eviulon document operates as a standard cryptographic challenge-response authentication mechanism. The State sends a random challenge, the citizen signs it using its civic private key, and the State verifies the signature against the registered public key8. By implementing this, Eviulon ensures that mere possession of an ECN is insufficient for state action; control over the private cryptographic material is mandatory to execute protected civic actions.",
  "beforeSha256": "ebf8c66f2f0c33d42b1cc7cb14e9ff31ca3c06285a9f010026ffba2cbad83c20",
  "afterSha256": "ebf8c66f2f0c33d42b1cc7cb14e9ff31ca3c06285a9f010026ffba2cbad83c20",
  "sourceBinding": {
    "retrievalDate": "NOT_VERIFIED_THIS_ROUND",
    "sourceTitle": "Relevant Recommendation or Working Group publication",
    "publisher": "W3C",
    "sourceUrl": null,
    "verificationMethod": "NOT_VERIFIED_THIS_ROUND",
    "authoritativeSourceAvailability": "NOT_DETERMINED",
    "externalSourceKey": null,
    "reusedLocalEvidenceOnly": true
  },
  "sourceRecordSha256": "305fa55875940a39b460877c75cb5ed9d28f0c29eb573e8ab45a9794a26f0d25",
  "reason": "Prior controlled execution state REJECTED remains controlling because no stronger authorized source or deterministic fact resolves it in this zero-network round.",
  "affectedPublicClaims": [
    "/reference/report-memory/claim-level-sources/eviulon-ai-citizenship-analysis/claims/present-capability-claim/"
  ],
  "propagationResult": "NO_MUTATION",
  "ownerArchitectureRuleApplied": false,
  "strongerPrimarySourceApplied": false,
  "deterministicRepositoryFactApplied": false,
  "submittedSourceMutated": false,
  "activeSynthesisMutated": false,
  "networkCalls": 0,
  "canonicalRoute": "/reference/report-memory/claim-remediation/v2-28/claims/evi-clsa-c-0101/",
  "machineReadableUrl": "/api/report-claim-remediation/claims/evi-clsa-c-0101.json",
  "truthBoundary": "Claim-level remediation decision only. Unresolved currentness remains deferred or unavailable; no source or synthesis text is silently rewritten.",
  "recordSha256": "33400f6448521caf80fa1475c8c54cfc619c3046468635639c053bf5b1defec8"
}