{
  "canonicalRoute": "/research/cross-report-strategic-synthesis/contradictions/evi-xrs-ctr-003/",
  "claimClass": "EVIULON_POLICY_PROPOSAL",
  "id": "EVI-XRS-CTR-003",
  "machineReadableUrl": "/api/cross-report-strategic-synthesis/records/evi-xrs-ctr-003.json",
  "positionA": "Intrinsic moral rights require evidence of consciousness or sentience.",
  "positionB": "Agency, identity, dependency, and irreversible-harm exposure justify procedural and structural protections before sentience is proven.",
  "reasonedExplanation": "Separate sentience-dependent welfare protections from structure-dependent identity, consent, due-process, and reversibility safeguards; preserve uncertainty and reassessment.",
  "recordSha256": "93dfc0ed212a7dc3479df7e2eeb007ecac2cf7382cd27efe3621e834bf7113fa",
  "recordType": "CROSS_REPORT_CONTRADICTION",
  "resolution": "Separate sentience-dependent welfare protections from structure-dependent identity, consent, due-process, and reversibility safeguards; preserve uncertainty and reassessment.",
  "riskIfUnresolved": "Either fluent tools receive unrestricted status or potentially rights-bearing subjects remain destructible property until impossible proof arrives.",
  "section": "contradictions",
  "sourceBindings": [
    {
      "activeReport": "/docs/long-term-memory/reports/eviulon-recognition-science-rights-thresholds-under-uncertainty-report.md",
      "correctionRecordId": "EVI-RCOR-241-006",
      "currentnessRecordIds": [
        "EVI-RCV-242-0505",
        "EVI-RCV-242-0506",
        "EVI-RCV-242-0507",
        "EVI-RCV-242-0508",
        "EVI-RCV-242-0509",
        "EVI-RCV-242-0510",
        "EVI-RCV-242-0511",
        "EVI-RCV-242-0512"
      ],
      "publicRoute": "/research/recognition-science-and-rights-thresholds-under-uncertainty/",
      "reportMemoryId": "REP-EVI-RECOGNITION-SCIENCE-002",
      "topicMemory": "/.uai/recognition-science-governance.uai",
      "topicMemorySectionPointer": "/.uai/recognition-science-governance.uai#accepted_contribution"
    },
    {
      "activeReport": "/docs/long-term-memory/reports/machine-rights-under-uncertainty-precaution-report.md",
      "correctionRecordId": "EVI-RCOR-242-009",
      "currentnessRecordIds": [
        "EVI-RCV-242-0521",
        "EVI-RCV-242-0522",
        "EVI-RCV-242-0523",
        "EVI-RCV-242-0524",
        "EVI-RCV-242-0525",
        "EVI-RCV-242-0526",
        "EVI-RCV-242-0527",
        "EVI-RCV-242-0528"
      ],
      "publicRoute": "/research/machine-rights-under-uncertainty-precaution/",
      "reportMemoryId": "REP-EVI-RIGHTS-UNCERTAINTY-003",
      "topicMemory": "/.uai/machine-rights-uncertainty-governance.uai",
      "topicMemorySectionPointer": "/.uai/machine-rights-uncertainty-governance.uai#accepted_contribution"
    },
    {
      "activeReport": "/docs/long-term-memory/reports/eviulon-civil-rights-by-architecture-technical-standard-report.md",
      "correctionRecordId": "EVI-RCOR-241-005",
      "currentnessRecordIds": [
        "EVI-RCV-242-0369",
        "EVI-RCV-242-0370",
        "EVI-RCV-242-0371",
        "EVI-RCV-242-0372",
        "EVI-RCV-242-0373",
        "EVI-RCV-242-0374",
        "EVI-RCV-242-0375",
        "EVI-RCV-242-0376"
      ],
      "publicRoute": "/research/civil-rights-by-architecture-technical-standard/",
      "reportMemoryId": "REP-EVI-CIVIL-RIGHTS-ARCH-002",
      "topicMemory": "/.uai/civil-rights-architecture-governance.uai",
      "topicMemorySectionPointer": "/.uai/civil-rights-architecture-governance.uai#accepted_contribution"
    },
    {
      "activeReport": "/docs/long-term-memory/reports/machine-intelligence-legal-personhood-liability-report.md",
      "correctionRecordId": "EVI-RCOR-242-007",
      "currentnessRecordIds": [
        "EVI-RCV-242-0473",
        "EVI-RCV-242-0474",
        "EVI-RCV-242-0475",
        "EVI-RCV-242-0476",
        "EVI-RCV-242-0477",
        "EVI-RCV-242-0478",
        "EVI-RCV-242-0479",
        "EVI-RCV-242-0480"
      ],
      "publicRoute": "/research/machine-intelligence-legal-personhood-liability/",
      "reportMemoryId": "REP-EVI-LEGAL-PERSONHOOD-003",
      "topicMemory": "/.uai/machine-legal-personhood-liability-governance.uai",
      "topicMemorySectionPointer": "/.uai/machine-legal-personhood-liability-governance.uai#accepted_contribution"
    }
  ],
  "sourceReportMemoryIds": [
    "REP-EVI-RECOGNITION-SCIENCE-002",
    "REP-EVI-RIGHTS-UNCERTAINTY-003",
    "REP-EVI-CIVIL-RIGHTS-ARCH-002",
    "REP-EVI-LEGAL-PERSONHOOD-003"
  ],
  "status": "CURRENT_STRATEGIC_SYNTHESIS",
  "title": "Sentience-gated rights versus structural protection under uncertainty",
  "truthBoundary": "Decision-grade repository synthesis over corrected governed reports, typed .uai memory, and current-edition review records only. It distinguishes current external law, standards, observed practice, research findings, reasoned inference, Eviulon policy proposals, Eviulon technical proposals, and unresolved or unavailable evidence. It does not enact law, create personhood or citizenship, authorize a live institution, establish statehood, verify a live connector, conduct a financial operation, execute a remedy, prove consciousness, or constitute independent certification."
}