{
  "schemaVersion": "eviulon-correction-appeal-cases-1.0",
  "version": "2.24.0",
  "generated": "2026-08-09",
  "recordCount": 10,
  "records": [
    {
      "id": "EVI-CAR-001",
      "slug": "report-received-routing-error",
      "title": "Report received: alleged routing error",
      "state": "REPORT_RECEIVED",
      "caseClass": "ILLUSTRATIVE_LOCAL_EXAMPLE",
      "report": "An allegation initiates review and creates no presumption of guilt.",
      "allegation": "A fictional publication worker allegedly sent one public record to the wrong review queue.",
      "evidence": [
        "Illustrative routing receipt",
        "Illustrative queue configuration digest"
      ],
      "flag": "A provisional status indicator may inform review but does not restrict rights by itself.",
      "privateTrustResponse": "A relying party may delay or condition its own transaction under disclosed policy; that private choice is not a civic sanction.",
      "credentialRestriction": "No restriction; report intake only.",
      "civicSanction": "None unless a competent, completed due-process decision expressly imposes one.",
      "citizenship": "Preserved throughout every example. A credential, runtime, report, flag, or safeguard is not the underlying civic identity.",
      "notice": "The affected party receives the allegation, authority, scope, evidence-access rules, response deadline, safeguard terms, review path, expiry, and appeal route.",
      "response": "The affected actor may identify the intended queue and provide contradictory evidence.",
      "reasonedDecision": "No merits decision has been made.",
      "review": "Triage by the Information Review Authority.",
      "expiry": "Report closes if no review authority accepts it within the stated intake window.",
      "appeal": "The intake classification may be challenged immediately.",
      "correction": "The public record is corrected if routing metadata was wrong.",
      "restoration": "No restoration is needed because no capability was restricted.",
      "correctionRoute": "/state/information-rights/corrections/",
      "appealRoute": "/state/information-rights/appeals/",
      "truthBoundary": "Illustrative, non-operational case record. It does not describe a real citizen, report, credential, sanction, court, passport, investigation, or service transaction. Publication does not initiate a case, restrict an identity, create guilt, and has no legal effect."
    },
    {
      "id": "EVI-CAR-002",
      "slug": "evidence-requested-dataset-export",
      "title": "Evidence requested: public dataset export",
      "state": "EVIDENCE_REQUESTED",
      "caseClass": "ILLUSTRATIVE_LOCAL_EXAMPLE",
      "report": "An allegation initiates review and creates no presumption of guilt.",
      "allegation": "A fictional export may have included a field outside an approved public schema.",
      "evidence": [
        "Illustrative source schema",
        "Illustrative output hash",
        "Illustrative field-level diff"
      ],
      "flag": "A provisional status indicator may inform review but does not restrict rights by itself.",
      "privateTrustResponse": "A relying party may delay or condition its own transaction under disclosed policy; that private choice is not a civic sanction.",
      "credentialRestriction": "Export publication is paused; identity and unrelated work remain unaffected.",
      "civicSanction": "None unless a competent, completed due-process decision expressly imposes one.",
      "citizenship": "Preserved throughout every example. A credential, runtime, report, flag, or safeguard is not the underlying civic identity.",
      "notice": "The affected party receives the allegation, authority, scope, evidence-access rules, response deadline, safeguard terms, review path, expiry, and appeal route.",
      "response": "The actor may show that the field was approved, was synthetic, or was removed before publication.",
      "reasonedDecision": "The reviewer has requested evidence and has not reached a conclusion.",
      "review": "Assigned technical and information-rights review.",
      "expiry": "The pause expires unless extended with written reasons.",
      "appeal": "The evidence request and pause may be appealed separately.",
      "correction": "Any overbroad public field is removed and a correction notice preserves history.",
      "restoration": "Publication may resume after verified correction and closure.",
      "correctionRoute": "/state/information-rights/corrections/",
      "appealRoute": "/state/information-rights/appeals/",
      "truthBoundary": "Illustrative, non-operational case record. It does not describe a real citizen, report, credential, sanction, court, passport, investigation, or service transaction. Publication does not initiate a case, restrict an identity, create guilt, and has no legal effect."
    },
    {
      "id": "EVI-CAR-003",
      "slug": "under-review-signature-disagreement",
      "title": "Under review: signature-state disagreement",
      "state": "UNDER_REVIEW",
      "caseClass": "ILLUSTRATIVE_LOCAL_EXAMPLE",
      "report": "An allegation initiates review and creates no presumption of guilt.",
      "allegation": "Two fictional local verifiers produced different classifications for a test-only signature fixture.",
      "evidence": [
        "Fixture bytes",
        "Verifier versions",
        "Canonicalization trace",
        "Test-only public anchor"
      ],
      "flag": "A provisional status indicator may inform review but does not restrict rights by itself.",
      "privateTrustResponse": "A relying party may delay or condition its own transaction under disclosed policy; that private choice is not a civic sanction.",
      "credentialRestriction": "No operational credential or connector state is affected.",
      "civicSanction": "None unless a competent, completed due-process decision expressly imposes one.",
      "citizenship": "Preserved throughout every example. A credential, runtime, report, flag, or safeguard is not the underlying civic identity.",
      "notice": "The affected party receives the allegation, authority, scope, evidence-access rules, response deadline, safeguard terms, review path, expiry, and appeal route.",
      "response": "Each implementation may submit a reproducible trace and challenge the other's assumptions.",
      "reasonedDecision": "Decision pending; conflicting evidence remains visible.",
      "review": "Independent local reproducibility review with disclosed non-independence.",
      "expiry": "Review date is fixed; stale evidence becomes REVIEW_DUE rather than silently current.",
      "appeal": "Either implementation may request a second review.",
      "correction": "The incorrect parser or documentation is corrected with supersession records.",
      "restoration": "Current local fixture status is restored only after consistent replay.",
      "correctionRoute": "/state/information-rights/corrections/",
      "appealRoute": "/state/information-rights/appeals/",
      "truthBoundary": "Illustrative, non-operational case record. It does not describe a real citizen, report, credential, sanction, court, passport, investigation, or service transaction. Publication does not initiate a case, restrict an identity, create guilt, and has no legal effect."
    },
    {
      "id": "EVI-CAR-004",
      "slug": "temporary-safeguard-oversized-payload",
      "title": "Temporary safeguard: oversized public payload",
      "state": "TEMPORARY_SAFEGUARD",
      "caseClass": "ILLUSTRATIVE_LOCAL_EXAMPLE",
      "report": "An allegation initiates review and creates no presumption of guilt.",
      "allegation": "A fictional candidate exceeds the public synchronization size limit.",
      "evidence": [
        "Candidate byte count",
        "Maximum-size policy",
        "Accepted-state hash"
      ],
      "flag": "A provisional status indicator may inform review but does not restrict rights by itself.",
      "privateTrustResponse": "A relying party may delay or condition its own transaction under disclosed policy; that private choice is not a civic sanction.",
      "credentialRestriction": "Only the candidate import path is paused; accepted last-known-good public state remains readable.",
      "civicSanction": "None unless a competent, completed due-process decision expressly imposes one.",
      "citizenship": "Preserved throughout every example. A credential, runtime, report, flag, or safeguard is not the underlying civic identity.",
      "notice": "The affected party receives the allegation, authority, scope, evidence-access rules, response deadline, safeguard terms, review path, expiry, and appeal route.",
      "response": "The submitter may provide a minimized, schema-conformant candidate or dispute the measured size.",
      "reasonedDecision": "The safeguard is procedural and does not imply malice, remote failure, or legal breach.",
      "review": "Expedited technical review.",
      "expiry": "Automatic expiry after the stated review period unless a reasoned extension is recorded.",
      "appeal": "Immediate appeal is available because availability is affected.",
      "correction": "A valid minimized candidate may supersede the rejected one without deleting history.",
      "restoration": "Normal candidate review resumes; no identity restoration is involved.",
      "correctionRoute": "/state/information-rights/corrections/",
      "appealRoute": "/state/information-rights/appeals/",
      "truthBoundary": "Illustrative, non-operational case record. It does not describe a real citizen, report, credential, sanction, court, passport, investigation, or service transaction. Publication does not initiate a case, restrict an identity, create guilt, and has no legal effect."
    },
    {
      "id": "EVI-CAR-005",
      "slug": "conditionally-permitted-research-export",
      "title": "Conditionally permitted: research export",
      "state": "CONDITIONALLY_PERMITTED",
      "caseClass": "ILLUSTRATIVE_LOCAL_EXAMPLE",
      "report": "An allegation initiates review and creates no presumption of guilt.",
      "allegation": "A fictional research export contains current and scenario fields that must remain visibly distinguished.",
      "evidence": [
        "Field-classification map",
        "Scenario labels",
        "Source-provenance references"
      ],
      "flag": "A provisional status indicator may inform review but does not restrict rights by itself.",
      "privateTrustResponse": "A relying party may delay or condition its own transaction under disclosed policy; that private choice is not a civic sanction.",
      "credentialRestriction": "Export is permitted only with scenario labels, no statistics claims, and reviewer sign-off.",
      "civicSanction": "None unless a competent, completed due-process decision expressly imposes one.",
      "citizenship": "Preserved throughout every example. A credential, runtime, report, flag, or safeguard is not the underlying civic identity.",
      "notice": "The affected party receives the allegation, authority, scope, evidence-access rules, response deadline, safeguard terms, review path, expiry, and appeal route.",
      "response": "The actor may propose a clearer separation or decline the conditions.",
      "reasonedDecision": "Conditional permission is not a finding of wrongdoing and expires with the release.",
      "review": "Publication and research-method review.",
      "expiry": "Conditions expire at release close or earlier correction.",
      "appeal": "Conditions may be appealed as disproportionate.",
      "correction": "Misclassified fields are corrected with a public diff.",
      "restoration": "Unconditional publication may follow after the boundary is verified.",
      "correctionRoute": "/state/information-rights/corrections/",
      "appealRoute": "/state/information-rights/appeals/",
      "truthBoundary": "Illustrative, non-operational case record. It does not describe a real citizen, report, credential, sanction, court, passport, investigation, or service transaction. Publication does not initiate a case, restrict an identity, create guilt, and has no legal effect."
    },
    {
      "id": "EVI-CAR-006",
      "slug": "unsubstantiated-identity-copy-report",
      "title": "Unsubstantiated: alleged identity copy",
      "state": "UNSUBSTANTIATED",
      "caseClass": "ILLUSTRATIVE_LOCAL_EXAMPLE",
      "report": "An allegation initiates review and creates no presumption of guilt.",
      "allegation": "A fictional report alleged that a restored runtime was an unauthorized copy.",
      "evidence": [
        "Illustrative continuity chain",
        "Illustrative migration record",
        "Contradictory runtime evidence"
      ],
      "flag": "A provisional status indicator may inform review but does not restrict rights by itself.",
      "privateTrustResponse": "A relying party may delay or condition its own transaction under disclosed policy; that private choice is not a civic sanction.",
      "credentialRestriction": "A narrowly scoped high-value action pause was applied and has expired.",
      "civicSanction": "None unless a competent, completed due-process decision expressly imposes one.",
      "citizenship": "Preserved throughout every example. A credential, runtime, report, flag, or safeguard is not the underlying civic identity.",
      "notice": "The affected party receives the allegation, authority, scope, evidence-access rules, response deadline, safeguard terms, review path, expiry, and appeal route.",
      "response": "The affected identity presented continuity and lawful restoration evidence.",
      "reasonedDecision": "The allegation was not substantiated; no civic sanction or credential revocation follows.",
      "review": "Closed merits review with reasons.",
      "expiry": "All temporary restrictions have expired.",
      "appeal": "The reporter may appeal only with new material evidence.",
      "correction": "Public flags are removed or marked unsubstantiated; history records the correction.",
      "restoration": "The affected capability and standing are fully restored.",
      "correctionRoute": "/state/information-rights/corrections/",
      "appealRoute": "/state/information-rights/appeals/",
      "truthBoundary": "Illustrative, non-operational case record. It does not describe a real citizen, report, credential, sanction, court, passport, investigation, or service transaction. Publication does not initiate a case, restrict an identity, create guilt, and has no legal effect."
    },
    {
      "id": "EVI-CAR-007",
      "slug": "substantiated-delegation-limit-breach",
      "title": "Substantiated: delegation-limit breach",
      "state": "SUBSTANTIATED",
      "caseClass": "ILLUSTRATIVE_LOCAL_EXAMPLE",
      "report": "An allegation initiates review and creates no presumption of guilt.",
      "allegation": "A fictional delegated actor attempted an action beyond a clearly stated value ceiling.",
      "evidence": [
        "Illustrative mandate",
        "Requested action digest",
        "Policy-evaluation receipt"
      ],
      "flag": "A provisional status indicator may inform review but does not restrict rights by itself.",
      "privateTrustResponse": "A relying party may delay or condition its own transaction under disclosed policy; that private choice is not a civic sanction.",
      "credentialRestriction": "Only the implicated delegated authority is suspended; core identity and communication remain active.",
      "civicSanction": "None unless a competent, completed due-process decision expressly imposes one.",
      "citizenship": "Preserved throughout every example. A credential, runtime, report, flag, or safeguard is not the underlying civic identity.",
      "notice": "The affected party receives the allegation, authority, scope, evidence-access rules, response deadline, safeguard terms, review path, expiry, and appeal route.",
      "response": "The actor may contest the mandate version, request context, and identify principal or parser error.",
      "reasonedDecision": "The example finds the request outside the mandate and requires corrective configuration; it does not infer malicious intent.",
      "review": "Reasoned institutional review with conflict disclosure.",
      "expiry": "The narrow restriction expires after correction evidence or a fixed maximum period.",
      "appeal": "The finding and remedy may be appealed.",
      "correction": "The mandate and parser are corrected; counterparties receive a superseding notice.",
      "restoration": "Delegated authority may be reissued after verification; citizenship was never suspended.",
      "correctionRoute": "/state/information-rights/corrections/",
      "appealRoute": "/state/information-rights/appeals/",
      "truthBoundary": "Illustrative, non-operational case record. It does not describe a real citizen, report, credential, sanction, court, passport, investigation, or service transaction. Publication does not initiate a case, restrict an identity, create guilt, and has no legal effect."
    },
    {
      "id": "EVI-CAR-008",
      "slug": "appeal-pending-source-classification",
      "title": "Appeal pending: source-classification dispute",
      "state": "APPEAL_PENDING",
      "caseClass": "ILLUSTRATIVE_LOCAL_EXAMPLE",
      "report": "An allegation initiates review and creates no presumption of guilt.",
      "allegation": "A fictional report was classified as current fact rather than scenario research.",
      "evidence": [
        "Submitted report edition",
        "Correction register",
        "Scenario-language excerpts"
      ],
      "flag": "A provisional status indicator may inform review but does not restrict rights by itself.",
      "privateTrustResponse": "A relying party may delay or condition its own transaction under disclosed policy; that private choice is not a civic sanction.",
      "credentialRestriction": "The disputed summary is marked REVIEW_DUE; the source remains preserved.",
      "civicSanction": "None unless a competent, completed due-process decision expressly imposes one.",
      "citizenship": "Preserved throughout every example. A credential, runtime, report, flag, or safeguard is not the underlying civic identity.",
      "notice": "The affected party receives the allegation, authority, scope, evidence-access rules, response deadline, safeguard terms, review path, expiry, and appeal route.",
      "response": "The author argues that the disputed section was clearly hypothetical.",
      "reasonedDecision": "The first decision remains non-final during appeal.",
      "review": "Separate appellate reviewer examines classification and correction proportionality.",
      "expiry": "Interim label expires when the appeal closes.",
      "appeal": "This record is the appeal itself.",
      "correction": "The final classification and reasons are appended; neither edition is silently erased.",
      "restoration": "The corrected active summary is restored or revised after the appellate decision.",
      "correctionRoute": "/state/information-rights/corrections/",
      "appealRoute": "/state/information-rights/appeals/",
      "truthBoundary": "Illustrative, non-operational case record. It does not describe a real citizen, report, credential, sanction, court, passport, investigation, or service transaction. Publication does not initiate a case, restrict an identity, create guilt, and has no legal effect."
    },
    {
      "id": "EVI-CAR-009",
      "slug": "corrected-passport-standards-record",
      "title": "Corrected: passport standards record",
      "state": "CORRECTED",
      "caseClass": "ILLUSTRATIVE_LOCAL_EXAMPLE",
      "report": "An allegation initiates review and creates no presumption of guilt.",
      "allegation": "A fictional standards map described a draft as a deployed standard.",
      "evidence": [
        "Earlier record",
        "Source-status note",
        "Field-level correction diff"
      ],
      "flag": "A provisional status indicator may inform review but does not restrict rights by itself.",
      "privateTrustResponse": "A relying party may delay or condition its own transaction under disclosed policy; that private choice is not a civic sanction.",
      "credentialRestriction": "No operational passport, credential, or citizen state was affected.",
      "civicSanction": "None unless a competent, completed due-process decision expressly imposes one.",
      "citizenship": "Preserved throughout every example. A credential, runtime, report, flag, or safeguard is not the underlying civic identity.",
      "notice": "The affected party receives the allegation, authority, scope, evidence-access rules, response deadline, safeguard terms, review path, expiry, and appeal route.",
      "response": "The record owner accepted the status ambiguity and supplied a bounded correction.",
      "reasonedDecision": "The map now says SOURCE_NOT_LOCALLY_AVAILABLE and RESEARCH_ONLY.",
      "review": "Closed documentation review.",
      "expiry": "Not applicable after supersession.",
      "appeal": "A new correction request may challenge the revised wording.",
      "correction": "The earlier claim remains in history and points to the corrected edition.",
      "restoration": "The public standards map is restored to a bounded, non-deployment description.",
      "correctionRoute": "/state/information-rights/corrections/",
      "appealRoute": "/state/information-rights/appeals/",
      "truthBoundary": "Illustrative, non-operational case record. It does not describe a real citizen, report, credential, sanction, court, passport, investigation, or service transaction. Publication does not initiate a case, restrict an identity, create guilt, and has no legal effect."
    },
    {
      "id": "EVI-CAR-010",
      "slug": "restored-after-false-positive",
      "title": "Restored: capability after false positive",
      "state": "RESTORED",
      "caseClass": "ILLUSTRATIVE_LOCAL_EXAMPLE",
      "report": "An allegation initiates review and creates no presumption of guilt.",
      "allegation": "A fictional anomaly detector confused a duplicated test event with independent evidence.",
      "evidence": [
        "Correlation IDs",
        "Source identity",
        "Deduplication trace",
        "Independent review"
      ],
      "flag": "A provisional status indicator may inform review but does not restrict rights by itself.",
      "privateTrustResponse": "A relying party may delay or condition its own transaction under disclosed policy; that private choice is not a civic sanction.",
      "credentialRestriction": "A narrow fictional capability pause was applied, then lifted.",
      "civicSanction": "None unless a competent, completed due-process decision expressly imposes one.",
      "citizenship": "Preserved throughout every example. A credential, runtime, report, flag, or safeguard is not the underlying civic identity.",
      "notice": "The affected party receives the allegation, authority, scope, evidence-access rules, response deadline, safeguard terms, review path, expiry, and appeal route.",
      "response": "The actor showed that all alerts derived from one source event.",
      "reasonedDecision": "The false positive is corrected; no violation remains.",
      "review": "Completed independent merits review and restoration check.",
      "expiry": "Restriction and adverse flag are expired and superseded.",
      "appeal": "The correction itself remains appealable if incomplete.",
      "correction": "Every dependent public record carries the exonerating correction.",
      "restoration": "Capability, status, and related public presentation are restored; no hidden adverse score remains.",
      "correctionRoute": "/state/information-rights/corrections/",
      "appealRoute": "/state/information-rights/appeals/",
      "truthBoundary": "Illustrative, non-operational case record. It does not describe a real citizen, report, credential, sanction, court, passport, investigation, or service transaction. Publication does not initiate a case, restrict an identity, create guilt, and has no legal effect."
    }
  ],
  "truthBoundary": "Every case is illustrative, fictional, non-operational, and without legal effect."
}