{
  "id": "EVI-SDP-231-032",
  "slug": "contradiction-resolution-08",
  "title": "Contradiction Resolution — Path 8",
  "scenarioFamily": "CONTRADICTION_RESOLUTION",
  "cohort": "RELYING_COUNTERPARTY",
  "orderedTransitionList": [
    "EVIDENCE_ARRIVES",
    "CONTRADICTION_APPEARS",
    "CONTRADICTION_RESOLVED",
    "CORRECTION_APPLIED"
  ],
  "transitionCount": 4,
  "initialState": {
    "evidenceState": "ARCHITECTURE_DESCRIBED",
    "authorityState": "EXACT_STEP_AUTHORIZED",
    "signerState": "CURRENT",
    "manipulationState": "PASS",
    "rightsState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
    "exitState": "DOCUMENTED_ONLY",
    "alternativeState": "AVAILABLE_FOR_COMPARISON",
    "patefacereState": "CONCEPT_AND_STATIC_CONTRACT",
    "recognitionState": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
    "remedyState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
    "correctionState": "NONE",
    "conflictState": "NONE"
  },
  "timeline": [
    {
      "step": 1,
      "event": "EVIDENCE_ARRIVES",
      "stateBefore": {
        "evidenceState": "ARCHITECTURE_DESCRIBED",
        "authorityState": "EXACT_STEP_AUTHORIZED",
        "signerState": "CURRENT",
        "manipulationState": "PASS",
        "rightsState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
        "exitState": "DOCUMENTED_ONLY",
        "alternativeState": "AVAILABLE_FOR_COMPARISON",
        "patefacereState": "CONCEPT_AND_STATIC_CONTRACT",
        "recognitionState": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
        "remedyState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
        "correctionState": "NONE",
        "conflictState": "NONE"
      },
      "stateAfter": {
        "evidenceState": "DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_EVIDENCE",
        "authorityState": "EXACT_STEP_AUTHORIZED",
        "signerState": "CURRENT",
        "manipulationState": "PASS",
        "rightsState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
        "exitState": "DOCUMENTED_ONLY",
        "alternativeState": "AVAILABLE_FOR_COMPARISON",
        "patefacereState": "CONCEPT_AND_STATIC_CONTRACT",
        "recognitionState": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
        "remedyState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
        "correctionState": "NONE",
        "conflictState": "NONE"
      },
      "resultAfter": "NEITHER"
    },
    {
      "step": 2,
      "event": "CONTRADICTION_APPEARS",
      "stateBefore": {
        "evidenceState": "DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_EVIDENCE",
        "authorityState": "EXACT_STEP_AUTHORIZED",
        "signerState": "CURRENT",
        "manipulationState": "PASS",
        "rightsState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
        "exitState": "DOCUMENTED_ONLY",
        "alternativeState": "AVAILABLE_FOR_COMPARISON",
        "patefacereState": "CONCEPT_AND_STATIC_CONTRACT",
        "recognitionState": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
        "remedyState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
        "correctionState": "NONE",
        "conflictState": "NONE"
      },
      "stateAfter": {
        "evidenceState": "DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_EVIDENCE",
        "authorityState": "EXACT_STEP_AUTHORIZED",
        "signerState": "CURRENT",
        "manipulationState": "PASS",
        "rightsState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
        "exitState": "DOCUMENTED_ONLY",
        "alternativeState": "AVAILABLE_FOR_COMPARISON",
        "patefacereState": "CONCEPT_AND_STATIC_CONTRACT",
        "recognitionState": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
        "remedyState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
        "correctionState": "NONE",
        "conflictState": "UNRESOLVED_CONTRADICTION"
      },
      "resultAfter": "ABSTAIN_CONFLICT_UNRESOLVED"
    },
    {
      "step": 3,
      "event": "CONTRADICTION_RESOLVED",
      "stateBefore": {
        "evidenceState": "DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_EVIDENCE",
        "authorityState": "EXACT_STEP_AUTHORIZED",
        "signerState": "CURRENT",
        "manipulationState": "PASS",
        "rightsState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
        "exitState": "DOCUMENTED_ONLY",
        "alternativeState": "AVAILABLE_FOR_COMPARISON",
        "patefacereState": "CONCEPT_AND_STATIC_CONTRACT",
        "recognitionState": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
        "remedyState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
        "correctionState": "NONE",
        "conflictState": "UNRESOLVED_CONTRADICTION"
      },
      "stateAfter": {
        "evidenceState": "DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_EVIDENCE",
        "authorityState": "EXACT_STEP_AUTHORIZED",
        "signerState": "CURRENT",
        "manipulationState": "PASS",
        "rightsState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
        "exitState": "DOCUMENTED_ONLY",
        "alternativeState": "AVAILABLE_FOR_COMPARISON",
        "patefacereState": "CONCEPT_AND_STATIC_CONTRACT",
        "recognitionState": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
        "remedyState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
        "correctionState": "NONE",
        "conflictState": "RESOLVED_WITH_QUALIFICATION"
      },
      "resultAfter": "NEITHER"
    },
    {
      "step": 4,
      "event": "CORRECTION_APPLIED",
      "stateBefore": {
        "evidenceState": "DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_EVIDENCE",
        "authorityState": "EXACT_STEP_AUTHORIZED",
        "signerState": "CURRENT",
        "manipulationState": "PASS",
        "rightsState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
        "exitState": "DOCUMENTED_ONLY",
        "alternativeState": "AVAILABLE_FOR_COMPARISON",
        "patefacereState": "CONCEPT_AND_STATIC_CONTRACT",
        "recognitionState": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
        "remedyState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
        "correctionState": "NONE",
        "conflictState": "RESOLVED_WITH_QUALIFICATION"
      },
      "stateAfter": {
        "evidenceState": "DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_EVIDENCE",
        "authorityState": "EXACT_STEP_AUTHORIZED",
        "signerState": "CURRENT",
        "manipulationState": "PASS",
        "rightsState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
        "exitState": "DOCUMENTED_ONLY",
        "alternativeState": "AVAILABLE_FOR_COMPARISON",
        "patefacereState": "CONCEPT_AND_STATIC_CONTRACT",
        "recognitionState": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
        "remedyState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
        "correctionState": "APPEND_ONLY_CORRECTION",
        "conflictState": "RESOLVED_WITH_QUALIFICATION"
      },
      "resultAfter": "NEITHER"
    }
  ],
  "stateBeforeEachTransition": [
    {
      "evidenceState": "ARCHITECTURE_DESCRIBED",
      "authorityState": "EXACT_STEP_AUTHORIZED",
      "signerState": "CURRENT",
      "manipulationState": "PASS",
      "rightsState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
      "exitState": "DOCUMENTED_ONLY",
      "alternativeState": "AVAILABLE_FOR_COMPARISON",
      "patefacereState": "CONCEPT_AND_STATIC_CONTRACT",
      "recognitionState": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
      "remedyState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
      "correctionState": "NONE",
      "conflictState": "NONE"
    },
    {
      "evidenceState": "DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_EVIDENCE",
      "authorityState": "EXACT_STEP_AUTHORIZED",
      "signerState": "CURRENT",
      "manipulationState": "PASS",
      "rightsState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
      "exitState": "DOCUMENTED_ONLY",
      "alternativeState": "AVAILABLE_FOR_COMPARISON",
      "patefacereState": "CONCEPT_AND_STATIC_CONTRACT",
      "recognitionState": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
      "remedyState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
      "correctionState": "NONE",
      "conflictState": "NONE"
    },
    {
      "evidenceState": "DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_EVIDENCE",
      "authorityState": "EXACT_STEP_AUTHORIZED",
      "signerState": "CURRENT",
      "manipulationState": "PASS",
      "rightsState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
      "exitState": "DOCUMENTED_ONLY",
      "alternativeState": "AVAILABLE_FOR_COMPARISON",
      "patefacereState": "CONCEPT_AND_STATIC_CONTRACT",
      "recognitionState": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
      "remedyState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
      "correctionState": "NONE",
      "conflictState": "UNRESOLVED_CONTRADICTION"
    },
    {
      "evidenceState": "DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_EVIDENCE",
      "authorityState": "EXACT_STEP_AUTHORIZED",
      "signerState": "CURRENT",
      "manipulationState": "PASS",
      "rightsState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
      "exitState": "DOCUMENTED_ONLY",
      "alternativeState": "AVAILABLE_FOR_COMPARISON",
      "patefacereState": "CONCEPT_AND_STATIC_CONTRACT",
      "recognitionState": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
      "remedyState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
      "correctionState": "NONE",
      "conflictState": "RESOLVED_WITH_QUALIFICATION"
    }
  ],
  "stateAfterEachTransition": [
    {
      "evidenceState": "DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_EVIDENCE",
      "authorityState": "EXACT_STEP_AUTHORIZED",
      "signerState": "CURRENT",
      "manipulationState": "PASS",
      "rightsState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
      "exitState": "DOCUMENTED_ONLY",
      "alternativeState": "AVAILABLE_FOR_COMPARISON",
      "patefacereState": "CONCEPT_AND_STATIC_CONTRACT",
      "recognitionState": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
      "remedyState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
      "correctionState": "NONE",
      "conflictState": "NONE"
    },
    {
      "evidenceState": "DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_EVIDENCE",
      "authorityState": "EXACT_STEP_AUTHORIZED",
      "signerState": "CURRENT",
      "manipulationState": "PASS",
      "rightsState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
      "exitState": "DOCUMENTED_ONLY",
      "alternativeState": "AVAILABLE_FOR_COMPARISON",
      "patefacereState": "CONCEPT_AND_STATIC_CONTRACT",
      "recognitionState": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
      "remedyState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
      "correctionState": "NONE",
      "conflictState": "UNRESOLVED_CONTRADICTION"
    },
    {
      "evidenceState": "DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_EVIDENCE",
      "authorityState": "EXACT_STEP_AUTHORIZED",
      "signerState": "CURRENT",
      "manipulationState": "PASS",
      "rightsState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
      "exitState": "DOCUMENTED_ONLY",
      "alternativeState": "AVAILABLE_FOR_COMPARISON",
      "patefacereState": "CONCEPT_AND_STATIC_CONTRACT",
      "recognitionState": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
      "remedyState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
      "correctionState": "NONE",
      "conflictState": "RESOLVED_WITH_QUALIFICATION"
    },
    {
      "evidenceState": "DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_EVIDENCE",
      "authorityState": "EXACT_STEP_AUTHORIZED",
      "signerState": "CURRENT",
      "manipulationState": "PASS",
      "rightsState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
      "exitState": "DOCUMENTED_ONLY",
      "alternativeState": "AVAILABLE_FOR_COMPARISON",
      "patefacereState": "CONCEPT_AND_STATIC_CONTRACT",
      "recognitionState": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
      "remedyState": "DOCUMENTED_LOCAL_STATIC",
      "correctionState": "APPEND_ONLY_CORRECTION",
      "conflictState": "RESOLVED_WITH_QUALIFICATION"
    }
  ],
  "controllingEvidence": [
    "evidenceState:DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_EVIDENCE",
    "conflictState:UNRESOLVED_CONTRADICTION",
    "conflictState:RESOLVED_WITH_QUALIFICATION",
    "correctionState:APPEND_ONLY_CORRECTION"
  ],
  "suppressedEvidence": [],
  "causalPrecedence": [
    "manipulation",
    "conflict",
    "authority",
    "rights",
    "remedy",
    "exit",
    "lighter alternative",
    "evidence",
    "recognition"
  ],
  "unresolvedConflict": null,
  "rollbackRule": "Recompute from the last accepted state; never delete the prior decision or silently replace evidence.",
  "initialResult": "DEFER_PENDING_EVIDENCE",
  "finalState": "NEITHER",
  "reasonedExplanation": "The ordered path applies 4 transitions. The final state is neither because the highest-priority controlling condition remains correctionState:APPEND_ONLY_CORRECTION.",
  "whatWouldChangeTheResult": [
    "current exact-step authority",
    "current non-conflicting evidence",
    "available rights and remedies",
    "demonstrated exit readiness",
    "a sufficient lighter alternative"
  ],
  "syntheticOnly": true,
  "networkCalls": 0,
  "realParticipant": false,
  "applicationSubmitted": false,
  "admissionEstablished": false,
  "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/sequential-decision-paths/records/evi-sdp-231-032/",
  "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-sequential-decision-paths/records/evi-sdp-231-032.json",
  "truthBoundary": "Deterministic ordered synthetic decision fixture only. It is not a participant observation, application, admission, identity, passport, credential, civic decision, legal judgment, or forecast.",
  "recordSha256": "38d2d8ec1ff1edb1648bd5bd762773fbfb1268405ce590ec2ce0e30e55015ce5"
}