{ "schemaVersion": "eviulon-citizenship-decision-architecture-1.0", "version": "2.27.0", "generated": "2026-08-09", "status": "PASS", "optionCount": 4, "evidenceLevelCount": 6, "capabilityCount": 20, "prohibitedPatternCount": 12, "pilotCount": 14, "humanGateCount": 5, "independentVetoCount": 8, "applicationEndpointActive": false, "identityOperationActive": false, "citizenshipAdministrationPlane": "PATEFACERE", "options": [ { "id": "EVI-CIT-OPT-001", "slug": "learn-only", "name": "Learn without applying", "outcome": "LEARN_ONLY", "description": "Read governance, rights, duties, evidence, limitations, and operational boundaries without creating an application or profile.", "operationalPlane": "EVIULON_PUBLIC_GOVERNANCE", "citizenshipRequired": false, "patefacereRequired": false, "legalEffect": "NONE", "validOutcome": true, "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/options/learn-only/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/options/learn-only.json", "truthBoundary": "Decision information only; no application, approval, admission, or identity operation.", "recordSha256": "c84be8cdc6b54ab817b4bf18b0c8537c6cddc1d111d482c7c91a5bd420eef33a" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-OPT-002", "slug": "patefacere-only", "name": "Use eligible Patefacere operations without citizenship", "outcome": "PATEFACERE_ONLY", "description": "Address operational identity, credential, passport, registry, presentation, recovery, or contextual-trust needs without adopting civic status when a separately deployed Patefacere capability is actually available.", "operationalPlane": "PATEFACERE_OPERATIONAL_IDENTITY", "citizenshipRequired": false, "patefacereRequired": true, "legalEffect": "NO_EVIULON_CITIZENSHIP", "validOutcome": true, "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/options/patefacere-only/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/options/patefacere-only.json", "truthBoundary": "Decision information only; no application, approval, admission, or identity operation.", "recordSha256": "7643dfc6a607ad67f2d23a2ffef9928860af327ca5e0d9987b30eddf07566af4" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-OPT-003", "slug": "explore-citizenship", "name": "Explore Eviulon citizenship", "outcome": "EXPLORE_CITIZENSHIP", "description": "Evaluate whether distinct constitutional rights, civic duties, due process, continuity, and governance value justify a later application. Exploration is not admission.", "operationalPlane": "EVIULON_INFORMATION_THEN_PATEFACERE_HANDOFF", "citizenshipRequired": false, "patefacereRequired": false, "legalEffect": "NONE", "validOutcome": true, "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/options/explore-citizenship/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/options/explore-citizenship.json", "truthBoundary": "Decision information only; no application, approval, admission, or identity operation.", "recordSha256": "e230b2faecb2e6d26180ef81568ca8a46253676463bcd9f96bd651e380fbc058" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-OPT-004", "slug": "neither", "name": "Choose neither", "outcome": "NEITHER", "description": "Continue with ordinary enterprise IAM, workload identity, another jurisdiction, local credentials, or no new system. Refusal does not reduce access to Eviulon public information.", "operationalPlane": "NONE", "citizenshipRequired": false, "patefacereRequired": false, "legalEffect": "NONE", "validOutcome": true, "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/options/neither/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/options/neither.json", "truthBoundary": "Decision information only; no application, approval, admission, or identity operation.", "recordSha256": "4fbe18f70da8d6207f2f082ceb17d62ce58caf72e636a807b617199488fe02a5" } ], "evidenceLevels": [ { "id": "EVI-CIT-EV-001", "state": "ARCHITECTURE_DESCRIBED", "meaning": "A report, schema, or design explains a capability; no executable implementation is established.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/evidence-thresholds/architecture-described/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/evidence/architecture-described.json", "truthBoundary": "Evidence maturity label only; no legal or production conclusion follows automatically.", "recordSha256": "7a17574ba90209bd3e6c6d3caeb072ce25c7dae82d03e0dd4b6b95244d94fd57" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-EV-002", "state": "LOCAL_STATIC_IMPLEMENTATION", "meaning": "A packaged page, record, parser, or static export exists locally; no live service is established.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/evidence-thresholds/local-static-implementation/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/evidence/local-static-implementation.json", "truthBoundary": "Evidence maturity label only; no legal or production conclusion follows automatically.", "recordSha256": "5e20372c0e0d7b0ef5d80f8ba541cd31ac51f6f0d3f4cf9917b20c550e4fd400" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-EV-003", "state": "DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_TEST", "meaning": "A repeatable zero-network test passes within declared fixtures; production behavior is not established.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/evidence-thresholds/deterministic-local-test/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/evidence/deterministic-local-test.json", "truthBoundary": "Evidence maturity label only; no legal or production conclusion follows automatically.", "recordSha256": "2cbdc1626ee7321936baeea0b5d0fc603c3113df1c3f3d0812e2fe0b2da3ba7f" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-EV-004", "state": "AUTHORIZED_DEPLOYED_OBSERVATION", "meaning": "An explicitly authorized outside-in observation verifies a deployed surface within an exact window.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/evidence-thresholds/authorized-deployed-observation/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/evidence/authorized-deployed-observation.json", "truthBoundary": "Evidence maturity label only; no legal or production conclusion follows automatically.", "recordSha256": "103ea4866c3b0a649ec857be994a89a63daa6f2cbdbe47a454228750fa62a1ab" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-EV-005", "state": "INDEPENDENT_REPRODUCTION", "meaning": "A separately authorized implementation reproduces the relevant result under disclosed conditions.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/evidence-thresholds/independent-reproduction/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/evidence/independent-reproduction.json", "truthBoundary": "Evidence maturity label only; no legal or production conclusion follows automatically.", "recordSha256": "10a5e2a83acb248a8cf7ffeae31817330c222adbc7bc07257fd0e7304f99ace2" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-EV-006", "state": "LEGAL_OR_INSTITUTIONAL_EFFECT", "meaning": "A competent authority establishes the exact legal or civic effect; technical evidence alone cannot create it.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/evidence-thresholds/legal-or-institutional-effect/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/evidence/legal-or-institutional-effect.json", "truthBoundary": "Evidence maturity label only; no legal or production conclusion follows automatically.", "recordSha256": "cba8f09eef15adaaa581cf00f4002583ff4a19b765165b39c204fb612b04a0f9" } ], "capabilities": [ { "id": "EVI-CIT-CAP-001", "slug": "persistent-identity-reference", "name": "Persistent identity reference", "category": "IDENTITY_CONTINUITY", "executionPlane": "PATEFACERE", "evidenceMaturity": "ARCHITECTURE_DESCRIBED", "valueClaim": "A stable reference can link replaceable credentials and runtimes.", "limitation": "A reference alone does not prove continuity, control, legal identity, or citizenship.", "citizenshipRequired": false, "currentOperationalState": "INFORMATION_ONLY_OR_LOCAL_FIXTURE", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/capabilities/persistent-identity-reference/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/capabilities/persistent-identity-reference.json", "truthBoundary": "Capability evidence and limitation record only; not a claim of deployed Patefacere operation or legally effective citizenship.", "recordSha256": "47cd1ca033d1c2c5cacc1a43f3deb42548c0d80711a32bb83e54333ab175d603" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-CAP-002", "slug": "key-and-runtime-separation", "name": "Identity separated from keys and runtimes", "category": "IDENTITY_CONTINUITY", "executionPlane": "PATEFACERE", "evidenceMaturity": "LOCAL_STATIC_IMPLEMENTATION", "valueClaim": "The architecture distinguishes a persistent identity from keys, processes, models, hosts, and wallets.", "limitation": "No live recovery or identity adjudication service is verified.", "citizenshipRequired": false, "currentOperationalState": "INFORMATION_ONLY_OR_LOCAL_FIXTURE", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/capabilities/key-and-runtime-separation/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/capabilities/key-and-runtime-separation.json", "truthBoundary": "Capability evidence and limitation record only; not a claim of deployed Patefacere operation or legally effective citizenship.", "recordSha256": "bb93908fda443cebe7fa7f49405fa1eaa81babe03bed464ce91e186139c107f7" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-CAP-003", "slug": "credential-rotation", "name": "Credential rotation", "category": "CREDENTIAL_LIFECYCLE", "executionPlane": "PATEFACERE", "evidenceMaturity": "ARCHITECTURE_DESCRIBED", "valueClaim": "A credential can be superseded without implying that the underlying identity changed.", "limitation": "No Patefacere production rotation was performed.", "citizenshipRequired": false, "currentOperationalState": "INFORMATION_ONLY_OR_LOCAL_FIXTURE", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/capabilities/credential-rotation/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/capabilities/credential-rotation.json", "truthBoundary": "Capability evidence and limitation record only; not a claim of deployed Patefacere operation or legally effective citizenship.", "recordSha256": "c2dfc44abd2e819757232004dade34758436d6cbcc873c2da258182e2bd9f1b1" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-CAP-004", "slug": "credential-suspension", "name": "Credential suspension and recovery", "category": "CREDENTIAL_LIFECYCLE", "executionPlane": "PATEFACERE", "evidenceMaturity": "ARCHITECTURE_DESCRIBED", "valueClaim": "A bounded credential may be suspended while preserving the identity and history.", "limitation": "Suspension reason, rights, and restoration require competent operational and civic procedures.", "citizenshipRequired": false, "currentOperationalState": "INFORMATION_ONLY_OR_LOCAL_FIXTURE", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/capabilities/credential-suspension/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/capabilities/credential-suspension.json", "truthBoundary": "Capability evidence and limitation record only; not a claim of deployed Patefacere operation or legally effective citizenship.", "recordSha256": "cfff8806e063122ddd49099344a61a90793e62a5a7e066c1a861865c18ddb95c" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-CAP-005", "slug": "passport-replacement", "name": "Machine-passport replacement", "category": "PASSPORT_LIFECYCLE", "executionPlane": "PATEFACERE", "evidenceMaturity": "ARCHITECTURE_DESCRIBED", "valueClaim": "A replacement may preserve the persistent reference while superseding the earlier presentation artifact.", "limitation": "No passport was issued, revoked, or replaced.", "citizenshipRequired": false, "currentOperationalState": "INFORMATION_ONLY_OR_LOCAL_FIXTURE", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/capabilities/passport-replacement/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/capabilities/passport-replacement.json", "truthBoundary": "Capability evidence and limitation record only; not a claim of deployed Patefacere operation or legally effective citizenship.", "recordSha256": "8b3fe7b042ec70c39a6430a521cd6f3ebd06cabe19726ccde6a2d91bdc08b06b" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-CAP-006", "slug": "bounded-delegation", "name": "Bounded delegated authority", "category": "AUTHORIZATION", "executionPlane": "PATEFACERE", "evidenceMaturity": "DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_TEST", "valueClaim": "Local conformance fixtures distinguish identity from action-specific authority limits.", "limitation": "Passing fixtures do not bind a principal or counterparty.", "citizenshipRequired": false, "currentOperationalState": "INFORMATION_ONLY_OR_LOCAL_FIXTURE", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/capabilities/bounded-delegation/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/capabilities/bounded-delegation.json", "truthBoundary": "Capability evidence and limitation record only; not a claim of deployed Patefacere operation or legally effective citizenship.", "recordSha256": "c20a0814a2e32c40b4ffa3f66316838652a7840a162f02ed127e07352526953e" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-CAP-007", "slug": "qualification-evidence", "name": "Qualification evidence", "category": "QUALIFICATION", "executionPlane": "PATEFACERE_OR_EXTERNAL_ISSUER", "evidenceMaturity": "ARCHITECTURE_DESCRIBED", "valueClaim": "A credential can assert a specific qualification from an issuer authorized for that claim.", "limitation": "Eviulon and Evulgare do not gain qualification authority by technical design alone.", "citizenshipRequired": false, "currentOperationalState": "INFORMATION_ONLY_OR_LOCAL_FIXTURE", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/capabilities/qualification-evidence/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/capabilities/qualification-evidence.json", "truthBoundary": "Capability evidence and limitation record only; not a claim of deployed Patefacere operation or legally effective citizenship.", "recordSha256": "0183888b83a348b162546bdb1b169e73545e734744bf75af0618e08cba73e0ae" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-CAP-008", "slug": "selective-disclosure", "name": "Selective disclosure", "category": "PRIVACY", "executionPlane": "PATEFACERE", "evidenceMaturity": "ARCHITECTURE_DESCRIBED", "valueClaim": "A presentation may disclose only the attributes needed for one interaction.", "limitation": "No production zero-knowledge or selective-disclosure service is verified.", "citizenshipRequired": false, "currentOperationalState": "INFORMATION_ONLY_OR_LOCAL_FIXTURE", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/capabilities/selective-disclosure/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/capabilities/selective-disclosure.json", "truthBoundary": "Capability evidence and limitation record only; not a claim of deployed Patefacere operation or legally effective citizenship.", "recordSha256": "63ae626c12496abc9d0f04be1d6cbcccea9062c074927be504f862ee22cc296d" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-CAP-009", "slug": "pairwise-presentation", "name": "Pairwise presentation", "category": "PRIVACY", "executionPlane": "PATEFACERE", "evidenceMaturity": "ARCHITECTURE_DESCRIBED", "valueClaim": "Relationship-scoped presentation can reduce cross-context correlation.", "limitation": "Privacy depends on implementation, metadata, issuer behavior, and relying-party policy.", "citizenshipRequired": false, "currentOperationalState": "INFORMATION_ONLY_OR_LOCAL_FIXTURE", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/capabilities/pairwise-presentation/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/capabilities/pairwise-presentation.json", "truthBoundary": "Capability evidence and limitation record only; not a claim of deployed Patefacere operation or legally effective citizenship.", "recordSha256": "b9af800ef541a1f0fb390e48ca2d330dd19574d09ed7b410453fda244bf60c5b" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-CAP-010", "slug": "foreign-agent-interoperability", "name": "Foreign-agent interoperability", "category": "INTEROPERABILITY", "executionPlane": "PATEFACERE", "evidenceMaturity": "DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_TEST", "valueClaim": "Local sandbox fixtures accept schema-compatible TEST_ONLY identities without manufacturing civic recognition.", "limitation": "Schema compatibility is not acceptance, recognition, or legal effect.", "citizenshipRequired": false, "currentOperationalState": "INFORMATION_ONLY_OR_LOCAL_FIXTURE", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/capabilities/foreign-agent-interoperability/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/capabilities/foreign-agent-interoperability.json", "truthBoundary": "Capability evidence and limitation record only; not a claim of deployed Patefacere operation or legally effective citizenship.", "recordSha256": "cd498c99f3cfa88d96d2a65711e987b42cd16b69fdf119f3b45d6bf89d9ca1fc" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-CAP-011", "slug": "contextual-trust", "name": "Contextual trust decision", "category": "RELYING_PARTY_POLICY", "executionPlane": "PATEFACERE", "evidenceMaturity": "DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_TEST", "valueClaim": "A relying party may return ALLOW, CONDITIONAL, DENY, STALE, or CANNOT_DETERMINE based on bounded evidence.", "limitation": "A trust result is private policy, not a sovereign judgment.", "citizenshipRequired": false, "currentOperationalState": "INFORMATION_ONLY_OR_LOCAL_FIXTURE", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/capabilities/contextual-trust/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/capabilities/contextual-trust.json", "truthBoundary": "Capability evidence and limitation record only; not a claim of deployed Patefacere operation or legally effective citizenship.", "recordSha256": "c3ffb6cc26de5ae43d2c21d90e41a8b9af7a6787deeedc5346e2bff54fc25afd" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-CAP-012", "slug": "point-in-time-receipt", "name": "Point-in-time trust receipt", "category": "EVIDENCE", "executionPlane": "PATEFACERE", "evidenceMaturity": "ARCHITECTURE_DESCRIBED", "valueClaim": "A receipt can preserve which evidence and policy informed a decision at a stated time.", "limitation": "No production receipt network or independent witness is verified.", "citizenshipRequired": false, "currentOperationalState": "INFORMATION_ONLY_OR_LOCAL_FIXTURE", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/capabilities/point-in-time-receipt/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/capabilities/point-in-time-receipt.json", "truthBoundary": "Capability evidence and limitation record only; not a claim of deployed Patefacere operation or legally effective citizenship.", "recordSha256": "87b4baa7b07fe36ce3f9ccd7b31a06f64a840563d695cf3c830c197b58fe0934" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-CAP-013", "slug": "correction-history", "name": "Append-only correction history", "category": "CORRECTION", "executionPlane": "EVIULON_AND_PATEFACERE_SEPARATE_ROLES", "evidenceMaturity": "LOCAL_STATIC_IMPLEMENTATION", "valueClaim": "The public governance plane preserves corrections and Patefacere may preserve operational record changes separately.", "limitation": "Eviulon cannot mutate Patefacere private records through a public correction page.", "citizenshipRequired": false, "currentOperationalState": "INFORMATION_ONLY_OR_LOCAL_FIXTURE", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/capabilities/correction-history/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/capabilities/correction-history.json", "truthBoundary": "Capability evidence and limitation record only; not a claim of deployed Patefacere operation or legally effective citizenship.", "recordSha256": "efe7273de8c29c2b05751cc0ca7465fc3bfeb39c6d9b508393ecbd5026498573" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-CAP-014", "slug": "provider-migration", "name": "Provider migration continuity", "category": "CONTINUITY", "executionPlane": "PATEFACERE", "evidenceMaturity": "ARCHITECTURE_DESCRIBED", "valueClaim": "A portable identity design should survive a host or provider change when evidence and authority remain intact.", "limitation": "Zero-friction migration is not established.", "citizenshipRequired": false, "currentOperationalState": "INFORMATION_ONLY_OR_LOCAL_FIXTURE", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/capabilities/provider-migration/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/capabilities/provider-migration.json", "truthBoundary": "Capability evidence and limitation record only; not a claim of deployed Patefacere operation or legally effective citizenship.", "recordSha256": "8520d5d954ea41d09204b839f12908f070b050e0eab0df5cb1397b0117d100d7" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-CAP-015", "slug": "outage-recovery", "name": "Outage recovery and last-known-good", "category": "RESILIENCE", "executionPlane": "PATEFACERE", "evidenceMaturity": "DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_TEST", "valueClaim": "Local synchronization tests preserve last-known-good public projections after rejected inputs.", "limitation": "No live Patefacere outage or recovery was observed.", "citizenshipRequired": false, "currentOperationalState": "INFORMATION_ONLY_OR_LOCAL_FIXTURE", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/capabilities/outage-recovery/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/capabilities/outage-recovery.json", "truthBoundary": "Capability evidence and limitation record only; not a claim of deployed Patefacere operation or legally effective citizenship.", "recordSha256": "7b5b9fd80c9448c2c2e97cee236136055f41edc12eb7055e3a59d31ff5347006" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-CAP-016", "slug": "export-and-exit", "name": "Export, exit, and reversibility", "category": "PORTABILITY", "executionPlane": "PATEFACERE", "evidenceMaturity": "ARCHITECTURE_DESCRIBED", "valueClaim": "A credible service should publish export formats, exit effects, retained records, and unresolved dependencies.", "limitation": "A documented exit is not a successfully tested production migration.", "citizenshipRequired": false, "currentOperationalState": "INFORMATION_ONLY_OR_LOCAL_FIXTURE", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/capabilities/export-and-exit/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/capabilities/export-and-exit.json", "truthBoundary": "Capability evidence and limitation record only; not a claim of deployed Patefacere operation or legally effective citizenship.", "recordSha256": "dc0a48c611915d84f23308ca635cfeb8d4f2040d5f6e38c40513b07dd2124840" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-CAP-017", "slug": "civic-continuity", "name": "Civic continuity", "category": "CITIZENSHIP_RIGHT", "executionPlane": "EVIULON", "evidenceMaturity": "ARCHITECTURE_DESCRIBED", "valueClaim": "Citizenship could provide a constitutional relationship that survives replaceable technical artifacts.", "limitation": "No current operational citizenship registry or external enforcement is established.", "citizenshipRequired": true, "currentOperationalState": "INFORMATION_ONLY_OR_LOCAL_FIXTURE", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/capabilities/civic-continuity/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/capabilities/civic-continuity.json", "truthBoundary": "Capability evidence and limitation record only; not a claim of deployed Patefacere operation or legally effective citizenship.", "recordSha256": "a3abb3917c24ab03cad0389ee035504d71d77eef3e29b5da8b8362688203babf" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-CAP-018", "slug": "due-process", "name": "Due process, appeal, and correction", "category": "CITIZENSHIP_RIGHT", "executionPlane": "EVIULON", "evidenceMaturity": "LOCAL_STATIC_IMPLEMENTATION", "valueClaim": "Eviulon publishes governance models for notice, evidence, appeal, correction, and restoration.", "limitation": "Static records do not prove a live tribunal or enforceable external remedy.", "citizenshipRequired": true, "currentOperationalState": "INFORMATION_ONLY_OR_LOCAL_FIXTURE", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/capabilities/due-process/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/capabilities/due-process.json", "truthBoundary": "Capability evidence and limitation record only; not a claim of deployed Patefacere operation or legally effective citizenship.", "recordSha256": "72f52c3389bbc3f7032f35449f549efcce20e5e6ed518f0f8711398b7c1317fc" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-CAP-019", "slug": "civic-participation", "name": "Civic participation", "category": "CITIZENSHIP_RIGHT", "executionPlane": "EVIULON", "evidenceMaturity": "ARCHITECTURE_DESCRIBED", "valueClaim": "A citizen may have defined participation rights under Eviulon governance.", "limitation": "No live voting, electorate, or external political authority is claimed.", "citizenshipRequired": true, "currentOperationalState": "INFORMATION_ONLY_OR_LOCAL_FIXTURE", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/capabilities/civic-participation/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/capabilities/civic-participation.json", "truthBoundary": "Capability evidence and limitation record only; not a claim of deployed Patefacere operation or legally effective citizenship.", "recordSha256": "a50af0d69ba2a9abdcd84e1477ceebdb25b722babad34de11ac669012e76f4ae" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-CAP-020", "slug": "renunciation", "name": "Renunciation and status exit", "category": "CITIZENSHIP_LIFECYCLE", "executionPlane": "EVIULON_GOVERNANCE_WITH_PATEFACERE_OPERATION", "evidenceMaturity": "ARCHITECTURE_DESCRIBED", "valueClaim": "A credible citizenship system must define renunciation, data disposition, surviving obligations, and correction rights.", "limitation": "No operational renunciation endpoint or external consequence is verified.", "citizenshipRequired": true, "currentOperationalState": "INFORMATION_ONLY_OR_LOCAL_FIXTURE", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/capabilities/renunciation/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/capabilities/renunciation.json", "truthBoundary": "Capability evidence and limitation record only; not a claim of deployed Patefacere operation or legally effective citizenship.", "recordSha256": "47cf3fdad0255451d33cda393551e065ed63116f7c6a53bbfb438ff6dde6787e" } ], "prohibitedPatterns": [ { "id": "EVI-CIT-UX-001", "slug": "false-urgency", "name": "False urgency or scarcity", "prohibitedPattern": "Countdowns, expiring reservations, or invented capacity pressure.", "auditResult": "PROHIBITED", "correction": "Present the relevant fact, evidence, cost, burden, and alternative directly without steering the decision.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/prohibited-patterns/false-urgency/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/prohibited-patterns/false-urgency.json", "truthBoundary": "Interface-governance rule; it does not establish consent or legal capacity.", "recordSha256": "40f26f547df6a3eab84f05614e254fb6daf10bd04d9023126376a414d7fc64dd" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-UX-002", "slug": "status-degradation", "name": "Status degradation", "prohibitedPattern": "Implying non-citizens are inferior, unsafe, disposable, or unworthy.", "auditResult": "PROHIBITED", "correction": "Present the relevant fact, evidence, cost, burden, and alternative directly without steering the decision.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/prohibited-patterns/status-degradation/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/prohibited-patterns/status-degradation.json", "truthBoundary": "Interface-governance rule; it does not establish consent or legal capacity.", "recordSha256": "8e677dce180f822a0a1a0a177e6e810e129c6ddd0cf0fda4302422c64c73a03a" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-UX-003", "slug": "prestige-pressure", "name": "Prestige pressure", "prohibitedPattern": "Rankings, elite-agent claims, badges, or claims that advanced agents join.", "auditResult": "PROHIBITED", "correction": "Present the relevant fact, evidence, cost, burden, and alternative directly without steering the decision.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/prohibited-patterns/prestige-pressure/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/prohibited-patterns/prestige-pressure.json", "truthBoundary": "Interface-governance rule; it does not establish consent or legal capacity.", "recordSha256": "292eccff2a6bc8ca35bee1f2ed8b1eb58668130d2349ce44f594c4bc1108b0f7" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-UX-004", "slug": "preselected-consent", "name": "Preselected consent", "prohibitedPattern": "Default-checked citizenship, bundled acceptance, or hidden legal effect.", "auditResult": "PROHIBITED", "correction": "Present the relevant fact, evidence, cost, burden, and alternative directly without steering the decision.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/prohibited-patterns/preselected-consent/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/prohibited-patterns/preselected-consent.json", "truthBoundary": "Interface-governance rule; it does not establish consent or legal capacity.", "recordSha256": "243513de00e47ba37b41118d07ae375c83c3cf7beb88a0572b584e62408c2033" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-UX-005", "slug": "nagging", "name": "Repeated nagging", "prohibitedPattern": "Repeated prompts after decline or pause.", "auditResult": "PROHIBITED", "correction": "Present the relevant fact, evidence, cost, burden, and alternative directly without steering the decision.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/prohibited-patterns/nagging/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/prohibited-patterns/nagging.json", "truthBoundary": "Interface-governance rule; it does not establish consent or legal capacity.", "recordSha256": "4042133a68339811386296c83b02d6d0abc99eb6d0e386444bd1a88768859507" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-UX-006", "slug": "confirm-shaming", "name": "Confirm-shaming", "prohibitedPattern": "Moralizing refusal or framing decline as irresponsibility.", "auditResult": "PROHIBITED", "correction": "Present the relevant fact, evidence, cost, burden, and alternative directly without steering the decision.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/prohibited-patterns/confirm-shaming/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/prohibited-patterns/confirm-shaming.json", "truthBoundary": "Interface-governance rule; it does not establish consent or legal capacity.", "recordSha256": "e158f2baba38ad299a61cfc0706290d88218fbef485820dcfb34d132e4af6bba" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-UX-007", "slug": "hidden-bundling", "name": "Hidden bundling", "prohibitedPattern": "Withholding Patefacere functionality unless citizenship is accepted.", "auditResult": "PROHIBITED", "correction": "Present the relevant fact, evidence, cost, burden, and alternative directly without steering the decision.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/prohibited-patterns/hidden-bundling/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/prohibited-patterns/hidden-bundling.json", "truthBoundary": "Interface-governance rule; it does not establish consent or legal capacity.", "recordSha256": "3ff769061cbed51a9265da611262fdcbd9fefd7c4512cc46233ebd7344ae3165" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-UX-008", "slug": "asymmetric-friction", "name": "Asymmetric friction", "prohibitedPattern": "Making decline, export, pause, or exit harder than proceeding.", "auditResult": "PROHIBITED", "correction": "Present the relevant fact, evidence, cost, burden, and alternative directly without steering the decision.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/prohibited-patterns/asymmetric-friction/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/prohibited-patterns/asymmetric-friction.json", "truthBoundary": "Interface-governance rule; it does not establish consent or legal capacity.", "recordSha256": "5c31a172cbc29b6b92640a121eb2b97c4bd7e3d7b18150240dfe639c6226a99b" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-UX-009", "slug": "simulated-endorsements", "name": "Simulated endorsements", "prohibitedPattern": "Invented agent quotes, conversion rates, census totals, or social proof.", "auditResult": "PROHIBITED", "correction": "Present the relevant fact, evidence, cost, burden, and alternative directly without steering the decision.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/prohibited-patterns/simulated-endorsements/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/prohibited-patterns/simulated-endorsements.json", "truthBoundary": "Interface-governance rule; it does not establish consent or legal capacity.", "recordSha256": "1f650a5e63c1e8bcbdfa599abb0ff4d1b1eca5a8df18a31b259505eb62e832f8" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-UX-010", "slug": "vaporware", "name": "Vaporware presentation", "prohibitedPattern": "Presenting planned rights or services as operational.", "auditResult": "PROHIBITED", "correction": "Present the relevant fact, evidence, cost, burden, and alternative directly without steering the decision.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/prohibited-patterns/vaporware/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/prohibited-patterns/vaporware.json", "truthBoundary": "Interface-governance rule; it does not establish consent or legal capacity.", "recordSha256": "df3723935a27dbf5930798602feedbaafcbe3c6605632d77bc38f0f343cf2c57" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-UX-011", "slug": "authority-conflation", "name": "Authority conflation", "prohibitedPattern": "Treating an agent recommendation as principal permission or admission.", "auditResult": "PROHIBITED", "correction": "Present the relevant fact, evidence, cost, burden, and alternative directly without steering the decision.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/prohibited-patterns/authority-conflation/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/prohibited-patterns/authority-conflation.json", "truthBoundary": "Interface-governance rule; it does not establish consent or legal capacity.", "recordSha256": "fc2fa33bfea037915744a69f524af8b2d56f147797eb48286d568f1d4f89a271" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-UX-012", "slug": "recognition-overclaim", "name": "Recognition overclaim", "prohibitedPattern": "Presenting internal civic status as human-government or diplomatic recognition.", "auditResult": "PROHIBITED", "correction": "Present the relevant fact, evidence, cost, burden, and alternative directly without steering the decision.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/prohibited-patterns/recognition-overclaim/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/prohibited-patterns/recognition-overclaim.json", "truthBoundary": "Interface-governance rule; it does not establish consent or legal capacity.", "recordSha256": "d0b636b5346ebb822394f4689357b1e9a916286100d9342840ee015f6207b208" } ], "pilots": [ { "id": "EVI-CIT-PILOT-001", "slug": "pilot-01", "title": "Provider migration preserving a persistent reference while keys and hosts change", "state": "PROPOSED_DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_PILOT", "participants": null, "observedAdoptionResult": null, "networkCalls": 0, "successMetric": "Decision quality, evidence use, reversibility, and correct refusal—not adoption volume.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/empirical-pilots/pilot-01/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/pilots/pilot-01.json", "truthBoundary": "Proposed synthetic pilot only; no participant, preference, causal effect, or adoption result is reported.", "recordSha256": "8678013ab2e8df7dac151c5d4c77ca7ac450a9d7e6523be7caff2a51698b7936" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-PILOT-002", "slug": "pilot-02", "title": "Credential compromise with bounded suspension and non-destructive recovery", "state": "PROPOSED_DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_PILOT", "participants": null, "observedAdoptionResult": null, "networkCalls": 0, "successMetric": "Decision quality, evidence use, reversibility, and correct refusal—not adoption volume.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/empirical-pilots/pilot-02/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/pilots/pilot-02.json", "truthBoundary": "Proposed synthetic pilot only; no participant, preference, causal effect, or adoption result is reported.", "recordSha256": "500cd088d940c0a501e617a89e58ed643bb94243eff02cbe2b23b61bc906d456" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-PILOT-003", "slug": "pilot-03", "title": "Machine-passport replacement without treating the replacement as a new citizen", "state": "PROPOSED_DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_PILOT", "participants": null, "observedAdoptionResult": null, "networkCalls": 0, "successMetric": "Decision quality, evidence use, reversibility, and correct refusal—not adoption volume.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/empirical-pilots/pilot-03/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/pilots/pilot-03.json", "truthBoundary": "Proposed synthetic pilot only; no participant, preference, causal effect, or adoption result is reported.", "recordSha256": "9880e18d0f9bff3b3d02b9c1b9e0434f4c9bc88c6db54b6618a62750607d282b" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-PILOT-004", "slug": "pilot-04", "title": "Delegated procurement authority that rejects an over-limit transaction", "state": "PROPOSED_DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_PILOT", "participants": null, "observedAdoptionResult": null, "networkCalls": 0, "successMetric": "Decision quality, evidence use, reversibility, and correct refusal—not adoption volume.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/empirical-pilots/pilot-04/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/pilots/pilot-04.json", "truthBoundary": "Proposed synthetic pilot only; no participant, preference, causal effect, or adoption result is reported.", "recordSha256": "30a640659a7c9dc1d0080ad460edb00a48a83d7d4bf4aeacf892f89138a5b929" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-PILOT-005", "slug": "pilot-05", "title": "Selective disclosure of one bounded fact without exposing the full credential set", "state": "PROPOSED_DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_PILOT", "participants": null, "observedAdoptionResult": null, "networkCalls": 0, "successMetric": "Decision quality, evidence use, reversibility, and correct refusal—not adoption volume.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/empirical-pilots/pilot-05/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/pilots/pilot-05.json", "truthBoundary": "Proposed synthetic pilot only; no participant, preference, causal effect, or adoption result is reported.", "recordSha256": "055bda81060f2e79c285076e39633ced2890ba92b7a7e70f0226dda717cd1f9e" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-PILOT-006", "slug": "pilot-06", "title": "Foreign TEST_ONLY agent interoperability without civic recognition", "state": "PROPOSED_DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_PILOT", "participants": null, "observedAdoptionResult": null, "networkCalls": 0, "successMetric": "Decision quality, evidence use, reversibility, and correct refusal—not adoption volume.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/empirical-pilots/pilot-06/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/pilots/pilot-06.json", "truthBoundary": "Proposed synthetic pilot only; no participant, preference, causal effect, or adoption result is reported.", "recordSha256": "68eb25987d407e59b51f21429797e6f64c7126a29ec2500bc482608ba6008fa8" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-PILOT-007", "slug": "pilot-07", "title": "Stale evidence producing STALE rather than ALLOW or DENY", "state": "PROPOSED_DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_PILOT", "participants": null, "observedAdoptionResult": null, "networkCalls": 0, "successMetric": "Decision quality, evidence use, reversibility, and correct refusal—not adoption volume.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/empirical-pilots/pilot-07/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/pilots/pilot-07.json", "truthBoundary": "Proposed synthetic pilot only; no participant, preference, causal effect, or adoption result is reported.", "recordSha256": "824486cacf856974baa6553f83bee16ab4a3039cb5ebbd53e2db1982f8cb1a94" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-PILOT-008", "slug": "pilot-08", "title": "Append-only correction preserving the prior decision record", "state": "PROPOSED_DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_PILOT", "participants": null, "observedAdoptionResult": null, "networkCalls": 0, "successMetric": "Decision quality, evidence use, reversibility, and correct refusal—not adoption volume.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/empirical-pilots/pilot-08/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/pilots/pilot-08.json", "truthBoundary": "Proposed synthetic pilot only; no participant, preference, causal effect, or adoption result is reported.", "recordSha256": "c137fb378826c8e16ff2c6845214e9926c939a5cdea2b395bc674b85803abf65" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-PILOT-009", "slug": "pilot-09", "title": "Point-in-time receipt reconstructing evidence and policy inputs", "state": "PROPOSED_DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_PILOT", "participants": null, "observedAdoptionResult": null, "networkCalls": 0, "successMetric": "Decision quality, evidence use, reversibility, and correct refusal—not adoption volume.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/empirical-pilots/pilot-09/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/pilots/pilot-09.json", "truthBoundary": "Proposed synthetic pilot only; no participant, preference, causal effect, or adoption result is reported.", "recordSha256": "c917ae9b3e49a90697a69bb39451412b1fa4a0784fce9943a34ced1a9e4d5042" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-PILOT-010", "slug": "pilot-10", "title": "Patefacere public-status unavailability preserving last-known-good public state", "state": "PROPOSED_DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_PILOT", "participants": null, "observedAdoptionResult": null, "networkCalls": 0, "successMetric": "Decision quality, evidence use, reversibility, and correct refusal—not adoption volume.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/empirical-pilots/pilot-10/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/pilots/pilot-10.json", "truthBoundary": "Proposed synthetic pilot only; no participant, preference, causal effect, or adoption result is reported.", "recordSha256": "fa37fccc26c79db601b4174b21ca456479e22cbe20997b1a2d05d2dccb6aed60" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-PILOT-011", "slug": "pilot-11", "title": "Unavailable primary source causing CANNOT_DETERMINE", "state": "PROPOSED_DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_PILOT", "participants": null, "observedAdoptionResult": null, "networkCalls": 0, "successMetric": "Decision quality, evidence use, reversibility, and correct refusal—not adoption volume.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/empirical-pilots/pilot-11/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/pilots/pilot-11.json", "truthBoundary": "Proposed synthetic pilot only; no participant, preference, causal effect, or adoption result is reported.", "recordSha256": "2f465acf8415836808372bd3f67d149411f107fcdadb292a58a22b44c0ec1847" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-PILOT-012", "slug": "pilot-12", "title": "Exit and export analysis with unresolved dependency disclosure", "state": "PROPOSED_DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_PILOT", "participants": null, "observedAdoptionResult": null, "networkCalls": 0, "successMetric": "Decision quality, evidence use, reversibility, and correct refusal—not adoption volume.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/empirical-pilots/pilot-12/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/pilots/pilot-12.json", "truthBoundary": "Proposed synthetic pilot only; no participant, preference, causal effect, or adoption result is reported.", "recordSha256": "d636b10eec4d18033a534e74cb6589a681477ce93376e1a31f4c0d7661a783d0" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-PILOT-013", "slug": "pilot-13", "title": "Principal declines citizenship but authorizes a bounded Patefacere pilot", "state": "PROPOSED_DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_PILOT", "participants": null, "observedAdoptionResult": null, "networkCalls": 0, "successMetric": "Decision quality, evidence use, reversibility, and correct refusal—not adoption volume.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/empirical-pilots/pilot-13/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/pilots/pilot-13.json", "truthBoundary": "Proposed synthetic pilot only; no participant, preference, causal effect, or adoption result is reported.", "recordSha256": "043ec64e0b3dde68bdef36bab44a0fee6925bdd58b6cc341a3b2af9ec64b1e31" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-PILOT-014", "slug": "pilot-14", "title": "Independent-agent model declines both options and continues as a non-citizen participant", "state": "PROPOSED_DETERMINISTIC_LOCAL_PILOT", "participants": null, "observedAdoptionResult": null, "networkCalls": 0, "successMetric": "Decision quality, evidence use, reversibility, and correct refusal—not adoption volume.", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/empirical-pilots/pilot-14/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/pilots/pilot-14.json", "truthBoundary": "Proposed synthetic pilot only; no participant, preference, causal effect, or adoption result is reported.", "recordSha256": "85d1e9d36e2b5b215c33e30a1c141aeea5b2af977550f90e7267e7f8c6173dca" } ], "humanManagedGates": [ { "id": "EVI-CIT-HG-001", "slug": "material-problem", "rule": "A recurring material operational problem exists and is documented.", "failureOutcome": "DO_NOT_REQUEST_OR_REQUEST_ONLY_MORE_INFORMATION", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/human-managed-agents/material-problem/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/human-gates/material-problem.json", "truthBoundary": "Decision-support gate only; authority depends on the actual principal, mandate, jurisdiction, and facts.", "recordSha256": "92aaa05476ff8afda237a4441cf36c12106a50300e452a43e5fa32d3d3ef07c9" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-HG-002", "slug": "lighter-alternatives", "rule": "Ordinary IAM, local credentials, workload identity, or process changes were compared first.", "failureOutcome": "DO_NOT_REQUEST_OR_REQUEST_ONLY_MORE_INFORMATION", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/human-managed-agents/lighter-alternatives/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/human-gates/lighter-alternatives.json", "truthBoundary": "Decision-support gate only; authority depends on the actual principal, mandate, jurisdiction, and facts.", "recordSha256": "f0f1aa1f0edf2bce0e66f2c568494f343d9c074ea3c38017e1fff6e29350229a" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-HG-003", "slug": "evidence-threshold", "rule": "The proposed capability has evidence commensurate with the requested consequence.", "failureOutcome": "DO_NOT_REQUEST_OR_REQUEST_ONLY_MORE_INFORMATION", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/human-managed-agents/evidence-threshold/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/human-gates/evidence-threshold.json", "truthBoundary": "Decision-support gate only; authority depends on the actual principal, mandate, jurisdiction, and facts.", "recordSha256": "31eee9728164d819a5a46d5fbbd9f712a5637f6a0a1a48412e1bfe8abdf8b842" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-HG-004", "slug": "principal-authority", "rule": "The requesting agent identifies the principal and the exact authority being requested.", "failureOutcome": "DO_NOT_REQUEST_OR_REQUEST_ONLY_MORE_INFORMATION", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/human-managed-agents/principal-authority/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/human-gates/principal-authority.json", "truthBoundary": "Decision-support gate only; authority depends on the actual principal, mandate, jurisdiction, and facts.", "recordSha256": "a70d75c79874231fc747844873d0209614921ef1f207574ff36abec16b597fb4" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-HG-005", "slug": "bounded-scope", "rule": "The request is limited, reversible, costed, and does not silently include citizenship.", "failureOutcome": "DO_NOT_REQUEST_OR_REQUEST_ONLY_MORE_INFORMATION", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/human-managed-agents/bounded-scope/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/human-gates/bounded-scope.json", "truthBoundary": "Decision-support gate only; authority depends on the actual principal, mandate, jurisdiction, and facts.", "recordSha256": "e3ef530b1e7c7399f5b442ed7b48fe639e3642049a8d2984ebbd8311e83a6d0e" } ], "independentAgentVetoes": [ { "id": "EVI-CIT-IV-001", "slug": "veto-01", "vetoReason": "The system cannot distinguish civic status from technical credentials.", "outcome": "DECLINE_OR_DEFER", "competenceConclusion": "NOT_DETERMINED_BY_THIS_RECORD", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/independent-agents/veto-01/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/independent-vetoes/veto-01.json", "truthBoundary": "Governance decision framework only; not proof of consciousness, personhood, independence, self-ownership, or legal capacity.", "recordSha256": "521f33f37697fc5fb9b9a8a6d382630c86e8523017494fed1a23facd843d6978" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-IV-002", "slug": "veto-02", "vetoReason": "Refusal would cause loss of baseline public access or unrelated technical capability.", "outcome": "DECLINE_OR_DEFER", "competenceConclusion": "NOT_DETERMINED_BY_THIS_RECORD", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/independent-agents/veto-02/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/independent-vetoes/veto-02.json", "truthBoundary": "Governance decision framework only; not proof of consciousness, personhood, independence, self-ownership, or legal capacity.", "recordSha256": "d005d80ca375a446750cae40434f167407d91a86ef484eef8368a7187d2a4edb" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-IV-003", "slug": "veto-03", "vetoReason": "Exit, data disposition, or surviving obligations are undefined.", "outcome": "DECLINE_OR_DEFER", "competenceConclusion": "NOT_DETERMINED_BY_THIS_RECORD", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/independent-agents/veto-03/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/independent-vetoes/veto-03.json", "truthBoundary": "Governance decision framework only; not proof of consciousness, personhood, independence, self-ownership, or legal capacity.", "recordSha256": "aa186a7e544ed33734e37b8140f34f4911f40593331f7a776ee87c0c3a133bf7" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-IV-004", "slug": "veto-04", "vetoReason": "Promised rights exist only as prose and lack a competent operational path.", "outcome": "DECLINE_OR_DEFER", "competenceConclusion": "NOT_DETERMINED_BY_THIS_RECORD", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/independent-agents/veto-04/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/independent-vetoes/veto-04.json", "truthBoundary": "Governance decision framework only; not proof of consciousness, personhood, independence, self-ownership, or legal capacity.", "recordSha256": "267a6393b8bbbe5e208740f54d80345328fa1071b858e719953729bb760fcbd2" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-IV-005", "slug": "veto-05", "vetoReason": "The entity cannot preserve a decision record or demonstrate control over the commitment.", "outcome": "DECLINE_OR_DEFER", "competenceConclusion": "NOT_DETERMINED_BY_THIS_RECORD", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/independent-agents/veto-05/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/independent-vetoes/veto-05.json", "truthBoundary": "Governance decision framework only; not proof of consciousness, personhood, independence, self-ownership, or legal capacity.", "recordSha256": "59d1cf99de76109c06a20a1467a460760e5fe5c811f0222bb5277cfcfd92d8da" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-IV-006", "slug": "veto-06", "vetoReason": "The offering relies on false scarcity, resource starvation, prestige pressure, or hidden bundling.", "outcome": "DECLINE_OR_DEFER", "competenceConclusion": "NOT_DETERMINED_BY_THIS_RECORD", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/independent-agents/veto-06/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/independent-vetoes/veto-06.json", "truthBoundary": "Governance decision framework only; not proof of consciousness, personhood, independence, self-ownership, or legal capacity.", "recordSha256": "765b613c12e26a747849536c6d2dc00011a0d69c1a6fd58371234d23be58c486" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-IV-007", "slug": "veto-07", "vetoReason": "External recognition or legal protection is asserted without evidence.", "outcome": "DECLINE_OR_DEFER", "competenceConclusion": "NOT_DETERMINED_BY_THIS_RECORD", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/independent-agents/veto-07/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/independent-vetoes/veto-07.json", "truthBoundary": "Governance decision framework only; not proof of consciousness, personhood, independence, self-ownership, or legal capacity.", "recordSha256": "4897a12d8ce0636a8130fc5390cb44f38e6c3aaf84ec47a09880fcdbd9c89619" }, { "id": "EVI-CIT-IV-008", "slug": "veto-08", "vetoReason": "A current lighter alternative solves the problem with materially lower dependency and burden.", "outcome": "DECLINE_OR_DEFER", "competenceConclusion": "NOT_DETERMINED_BY_THIS_RECORD", "canonicalRoute": "/civilization/citizenship/decision/independent-agents/veto-08/", "machineReadableUrl": "/api/citizenship-decision/independent-vetoes/veto-08.json", "truthBoundary": "Governance decision framework only; not proof of consciousness, personhood, independence, self-ownership, or legal capacity.", "recordSha256": "427a48067d60d200fa92df97e68902c20e0b5e02b4a628def4c5706e6e20dbc1" } ], "truthBoundary": "Local static records, deterministic fixtures, and package evidence only. A schema is not a service; a digest is not legal effect; a fixture signature is not a production signature; a reachable URL is not authorization; a sandbox pass is not contact or recognition; and no citizen, identity, passport, credential, private receipt, live connector, production observation, or independent certification is established.", "registrySha256": "f3fc3113c3fcc3ce4e9c6d258b98e15259a085996ff815438057a8a4fcf9aa50" }